Page 174

Isore Death...............................................+ Ch. Villette Confinement and banishment..........................O M Delamare Confinement or banishment...........................O I Ma.s.sieu, _eveque intrus_ Death...............................................+ P Cloots.

_Baron_ _Prussien_ Death...............................................+ G Portier Death, with respite.................................D Bezare Death...............................................+ Bourdon Death...............................................+ P G.o.defroy Absent upon commission..............................a

30. L'ORNE (ALENcON)

Valaze Death...............................................+ G La Hosdiniere Death...............................................+ Desrouais Death...............................................+ Dubois Death...............................................+ Beaupre Death, with respite.................................D Colombel Death...............................................+ Thomas "If the enemy invade our territories, I vote for "death; otherwise for detention."...................O Dugue d'a.s.sey "Having never been able to satisfy that I could "be both legislator and judge at once, I vote for "detention."........................................O I

Page 175

Fourney "The const.i.tution has not inflicted the "punishment of death upon Kings who may be guilty "of conspiracy. I am therefore for confinement "and banishment."...................................O

31. DEPARTMENT DE PARIS

Robespierre "The tyrant has deserved death. I vote for l'aine "death."............................................+ G Avocat d'Arras Danton, _avt_. "I vote for death"..................................+ G Collot d'Herbois, _comedian_ Death...............................................+ B Billaud Va -rennes Death...............................................+ B Cam.

Desmoulins Death...............................................+ G _journaliste_ Marat, Death...............................................+ A _journaliste_ La Vicomterie Death...............................................+ I Legendre, _butcher_ Death...............................................+

Page 176

Raffron Death...............................................+ Panis Death...............................................+ I Serjeant Death...............................................+ P Robert Death, with discussion as to time...................D Freron Death...............................................+ Beauvais Death, with discussion as to time...................D G Fabre d'Eglantine, Death...............................................+ G _journaliste_ Osselin Death...............................................+ G Robespierre le jeune Death...............................................+ G David, _artiste_ Death...............................................+ I Boucher Death...............................................+ Laignelot Death, with discussion as to time...................D I Thomas Confinement.........................................O Manuel "Laws of blood ought not to be among the "principles of a republic. The right of death "belongs only to nature. Louis is laid low "upon the ground; it is too easy to kill him, "for me to give the blow."..........................O G Dussault "A man may be, in my opinion an excellent patriot, "without putting to death his fallen enemy. I vote "for confinement and banishment."...................O P

Page 177

D'Orleans, called Egalite "My conscience tells me that Louis deserves death." + G

32. PAS DE CALAIS (ARRAS)

Garnet Death...............................................+ Duquesnoy Death...............................................+ S Le Bas Death...............................................+ S Guffroy Death...............................................+ Bollet Death...............................................+ Varlet "I vote for detention, because the nation ought "not to be influenced by sentiments of revenge."....O Enlard "My conscience points it out as my duty to have "nothing to do with the penal code. I am for "confinement and banishment.".......................O

Page 178

Dannon "The experience of those nations, who have put "their King to death, proves the contrary of "what you hope for. I am for confinement and "transportation."...................................O Personne Confinement and banishment..........................O Tho. Payne Confinement and banishment..........................O I Magniez Confinement and banishment..........................O

33. PUY DE DOME (CLERMONT)

Couthon Death...............................................+ G Gibergues Death...............................................+ I Maignet Death...............................................+ Romme Death...............................................+ S Soubrany Death...............................................+ G Rudelle Death...............................................+ Monestier Death...............................................+ La Loue Death...............................................+ Blanval Death, with discussion as to time...................D Du Laure Death...............................................+ P Bancal "The thirst of vengeance and of blood is found "only in individuals and factions; but never in a "great nation. I think, besides, that the "majority of French citizens would not vote for "actual death. A legislator ought to resist all "private pa.s.sions which surround him, to brave "with firmness every danger, and to obey nothing "but his conscience and his reason. I am for "detention."........................................O I

Page 179

Girot -pouzol Confinement and banishment..........................O ..

34. HAUTES PYReNNeES (SIC) (TARBES)

Barrere, _ex-n.o.ble_ Death...............................................+ B Ferrand Death...............................................+ M La Crampe Death...............................................+ Dupont "Behind this mausoleum I see a lion springing "from his den, and a dangerous enemy subst.i.tuted "in the place of a vanquished one. I vote for "confinement."......................................O Picque "I am for death; but not till after the cessation "of hostilities."...................................D Gertoux Confinement and banishment..........................O

35. Ba.s.sES PYReNNeES (PAU)

Sanadon, _eveque intrus_ "Being a legislator, I am not a judge. I cannot "vote but for confinement.".........................O P Pemartin "I am only at liberty to adopt a measure of "safety, which is, confinement or banishment."......O Comte "I am for the same punishment as the last "speaker."..........................................O Meillant "It Would, in my judgment, be a most mistaken "measure to cut off that head, which may one "day become useful. Confinement and "banishment.".......................................O

Page 181

Casenave "The acc.u.mulation of so many inconsistent powers "appears to me, notwithstanding the paradoxes "and sophisms which art has invented in the "course of this proceeding, to be a monstrous "tyranny, in which I am not willing to bear a "part. The only punishment applicable to Louis "is forfeiture of the crown.".......................O P Neveu "I fulfil my duty in voting for confinement.".......O

36. PYReNNeES ORIENTALES (PERPIGNAN)

Montegot Death...............................................+ Cazanies Death...............................................+ Biroteau "During the war I vote for confinement; and "after peace is established, for death."............O G Guyter Confinement and banishment..........................O I Fabre Absent through sickness.............................m

Page 182

37. HAUT RHIN (COLMAR)

Ritter Death...............................................+ La Porte Death...............................................+ Joannot Death...............................................+ Pflieger Death...............................................+ Dubois "I am not a judge. This character belongs to "none of us. If we were judges, we should "perform the duties Of such, and observe forms.

"I am for provisional confinement.".................O Albert Provisional confinement.............................O Rewbel Absent through sickness.............................m

38. BAS RHIN (STRASBOURG)

Laurent Death...............................................+ Bentabole Death...............................................+ Louis Death...............................................+ P

Page 183

Arbogast "I see the security of the republic depends on "the detention of Louis until time of peace.".......O Christiani Confinement.........................................O Dentzell Confinement.........................................O I Simon Absent upon commission..............................a G Rhull Absent upon commission..............................a S Erman Absent through sickness.............................m

39. RHONE ET LOIRE (LYON)

Dupuis, fils Death...............................................+ Dubonchet Death...............................................+ Pressavin Death...............................................+ Noel Pointe Death...............................................+ L'Eveque Death...............................................+ Cha.s.set "The convention, by its conduct in the violation "of judiciary forms, has convinced me that it "does not mean to place itself in the situation "of a judge. It is therefore not permitted me "to vote for death. I am for confinement until "the time of peace."................................O

Page 184

Michel "Reasons of state and of public good make me "incline to detention.".............................O Patrin "The existence of Louis is useful; his death.

"dangerous."........................................O Lanthenas "My opinion is, that Louis deserves death; but "only in case of a foreign war."....................O I Eusset Death...............................................+ Moulin "I vote for death; but not until all the Bourbons "are expelled.".....................................O Vitet Confinement.........................................O P Fournier Confinement.........................................O Bezaud Confinement and banishment..........................O Forest Confinement and banishment..........................O

40. HAUTE SAONE (VESOUL)

Gourdan Death...............................................+ Siblot Death...............................................+

Page 185

Bolot Death...............................................+ Dormier Death...............................................+ Vigneron Confinement and banishment..........................O Chauvier Confinement and banishment........................ .O Balivet Confinement and banishment..........................O

41. SAONE ET LOIRE (MACON)

Carra, _journal -iste_ Death...............................................+ G Gelin Death...............................................+ Guillermin Death...............................................+ Reverchon Death...............................................+ Bodot Death...............................................+ Guilmardet Death, with discussion as to time...................D Mailly Death...............................................+ Montgilbert "If the enemies invade the French territory, then "only I am of opinion that Louis should die.".......O Moreau Death...............................................+ Masuyer Confinement till the peace..........................O PG

Page 186

Bertucat "I cannot judge arbitrarily in this case.

"Perpetual confinement."............................O

42. LA SARTHE (LE MANS)