Page 162

Mont Mayan Death...............................................+ Delbret Death, with respite.................................D Cavaignan Death...............................................+ Alboys "The fear of poignards has no influence upon "my heart. No man can be punished but by virtue "of some law antecedent to the offence."............O Ansy Confinement.........................................O E Boygnes Confinement.........................................O Salleles Confinement.........................................O Cayla Absent through sickness.............................m

16. LOT ET GARONNE (AGEN)

Vidalot Death...............................................+ Paganel Death...............................................+ Boussion Death...............................................+ Fournel Death...............................................+ Claverie "I cannot p.r.o.nounce upon the fate of Louis but "according to the const.i.tution. Now the "const.i.tution speaks only of the forfeiture of "the crown."........................................O

Page 163

Gayet-la -Prade "Not to oppose the const.i.tution to the penal code, "I choose rather to vote for confinement."..........O Noguer "Having examined my conscience as a public man, I "give my opinion for detention."....................O Laurent Confinement.........................................O Laroche Confinement or banishment...........................O Dorisy Confinement.........................................O

17. LA LOZERE (MENDE)

Random Death...............................................+ I Servierre Death...............................................+ Monestier Death...............................................+ Barrot "As the death of Louis does not appear to me to "be necessary, or even useful to the republic, "I vote for detention.".............................O Aubert Confinement.........................................O Pellet Absent by commission................................a

Page 164

18. MAINE ET LOIRE (ANGERS)

Choudieu Death...............................................+ I De l'Aulnay Death...............................................+ G l'aine Le Paux Death...............................................+ P Le Clerc Death...............................................+ Perard Death...............................................+ De.

Houilliere "I am not a judge; I am merely a legislator.

"Consequently I can vote only for detention.".......O D'Andenac Confinement.........................................O l'aine D'Andenac Confinement or deportation..........................O le jeune Pilastre Banishment..........................................O De l'Aulnay Confinement.........................................O le jeune Le Maignan Confinement.........................................O

Page 165

19. LA MANCHE (COUTANCES)

Le Moine Death...............................................+ Ribet Death, with respite.................................D Le Tourneur Death...............................................+ Le Carpentier Death..............................................+ Bonnesoeur Death...............................................+ Laurence Death...............................................+ Havin Death...............................................+ Hubert Death...............................................+ Gervais -sauve "If the people had been willing to acc.u.mulate "upon my head the various functions of accuser, "juryman, and legislator, the burthen would have "been above my strength. I vote for confinement."..O Pinel I vote freely for detention.........................O Poisson Banishment..........................................O Engerrand Confinement.........................................O Bretel Confinement.........................................O

Page 166

20. LA MARNE (RHEIMS)

Prieur Death...............................................+ I Thuriot Death...............................................+ I Ch. Charlier Death...............................................+ De la Croix Death...............................................+ G de Constant De Villers Death...............................................+ Armonville Death, with discussion as to time...................D Drouet, Death...............................................+ I _maitre_ _de postes_ Vatelier Death...............................................+ Poulain Confinement.........................................O Blanc Banishment..........................................O I

21. LA HAUTE MARNE (LANGRES)

Guillardin Death...............................................+ Monnel Death...............................................+

Page 167

Roux Death...............................................+ Valdruche Death...............................................+ Rousseau Death, with discussion as to the time...............D La Loi Death...............................................+ Wandelin -court "I except against myself (_je me suis recuse_) "as judge; therefore I can vote only for "confinement, as a measure of general safety."......O

22. MAYENNE (LAVAL)

Bissy, Death...............................................+ le jeune Esne Death...............................................+ I Du Rocher Death...............................................+ Enjubaut Death...............................................+ I Serveau Death...............................................+ Villars "As the stability of a republic does not depend "upon the life, or death of a single individual, "and killing a tyrant is the last resource of "tyranny, I vote for confinement."..................O

Page 168

Le Jeune "The law of death not being applicable to the "case before us, I abstain from p.r.o.nouncing "judgment of death."................................O Plaichard -chottiere Perpetual confinement...............................O

23. LE MEURTHE (NANCY)

Malarme Death...............................................+ Leva.s.seur Death...............................................+ Bonneval Death...............................................+ Salle "My opponents have said, Do not appeal to the "people, because the people would not vote for "death; but for my part I wish not to vote, but "as the people would do."...........................O PG Molveau "Convinced that the day, on which the head of "Louis should fall, would probably be that of "the establishment of a new tyranny; and "apprehensive that his death would be for France, "what that of Charles 1. was for England, I give "my opinion for confinement or banishment.".........O

Page 169

Lalande Confinement and banishment..........................O Zangiacomi Confinement and banishment..........................O Michel Confinement and banishment..........................O

24. LA MEUSE (VERDUN)

Pons Death...............................................+ Moreau "The safety of the state does not appear to me to "require the death of Louis; I am for banishment."..O Roussel "Far from being dangerous, I think it sound "policy to let Louis live.".........................O Baroche "The judiciary power being no part of my "commission, I vote for confinement."...............O

Page 170

Harmand "I cannot bring the punishment from the penal, "code, since you have discarded all the forms "of it. I am therefore for banishment."............O Marquis "I am for provisional confinement.".................O Tocquot Confinement and banishment..........................O Humbert Confinement and banishment......................... O

25. MORBIHAN (VANNES)

Lequinio Death...............................................+ Audrein Death...............................................+ Le Hardy "Farewell to the liberty of my country, if we are "to be every thing at once. No! we are not judges.

"The death of Kings has never been salutary to "liberty. If the convention were to judge, I "should wish to see at least sixty of its members "excluded. I am for confinement."...................O G

Page 171

Corbel "A measure of safety is preferable to a rigorous "application of the law. I therefore vote for "provisional confinement."..........................O Gillet "Inaccessible to fear, I a.s.sert that capital "punishment is useless and dangerous.

"Perpetual confinement."............................O M Le Mailland Confinement and banishment..........................O Michel Confinement and banishment..........................O Rouault Confinement.........................................O I

26. LA MOSELLE (METZ)

Anthoine Death...............................................+ Bar Death...............................................+ Nentz Death...............................................+ I Thirion Death...............................................+ I Becker "Neither the menaces with which this tribune has "resounded, nor those puerile fears, with which "people have sought to fill us, shall make me "act contrary to my Sentiments, which is for "confinement and banishment.".......................O

Page 172

Merlin Confinement.........................................O Couturier Absent on commission................................a Blaux Confinement.........................................O I

27. LA NIEVRE (NEVERS)

Saustrault Death...............................................+ Damrobe Death...............................................+ Le Fiot Death...............................................+ Guilrault Death, with discussion as to time...................D Legendre Death...............................................+ La Planche Death...............................................+ Jourdan "The punishment of death is contrary to my "principles. I cannot put a fellow-creature to "death."....................................... ....O G

Page 173

28. NORD (DOUAY)

Merlin Death...............................................+ Duhem Death...............................................+ I Cochet Death, with discussion as to time...................D Fockedey Confinement.........................................O Senault Death...............................................+ P Carpentier Death...............................................+ P Pryese Death...............................................+ Sallengros Death...............................................+ Poultier Death, with discussion as to time...................D G Aoust Death...............................................+ G Gossuin Absent upon commission..............................a

29. OISE (BEAUVAIS)

Couppe Death...............................................+ I Calon Death...............................................+