Maybe Sashor and Chambers were onto something with regard to why. But the more important thing, the thing that had always mattered most to Lucas, was who?

Nothing had changed.

AVERY.

In her father's office, she sat at the computer and rooted around through his e-mail and figured out where the audio files were and started to listen to every call that had been recorded since the tip line went live. After a while she started to recognize the voice of the "nutjob" her father had been referring to.

"He didn't do it. You have to dig deeper. It's not over."

"How do you know this? Who are you?" the tip-line guy asked.

"I'm a dead man."

Click. Gone.

Later, the same voice again: "It was only supposed to be for a few hours, you see."

And again later, "I was only there once. I don't know where it was, but it wasn't that place."

"Sir, can you be more specific?"

"I can't. They're probably watching me. They're probably listening."

And the last one: "They were going to pin it all on me if I talked. They buried him in my backyard, for Chrissake."

Maybe everyone was right.

The guy was just crazy.

Or he wasn't.

She had to go back to the drawing board.

With Lucas in jail, she'd have the RV all to herself.

Scarlett

Drove like a lunatic, then pounded on the door until her fists hurt.

Lucas still hadn't responded to the texts she'd sent from Anchor Beach. And that had been several hours ago.

She'd forwarded the sketch of Miranda.

Wrote, This is the girl Sarah says was with us.

Then, On my way to you from Anchor Beach.

"Is Lucas here?" she asked when Ryan answered.

"No," Ryan said, sounding annoyed. "We had a fight after I bailed him out of jail."

"Is Miranda here?"

"She was." A look of confusion. "But she ran home to get some stuff she needed. Why?"

"Sarah said she remembered another girl being with us. She sent me a picture she drew of her." She pulled the picture up on her phone and held it out.

Ryan shook his head. "I don't understand."

"Have they ever met? Miranda and Sarah?"

"I don't think so. But if Miranda's . . . that would mean . . ." Ryan sat down, dropped his head. "That she targeted me?"

It was the conclusion Scarlett had come to on her drive, as well. "How did you meet her?"

"She came into the hotel where I work one night with some friends."

"She could have known who you were before she turned up." Scarlett's thoughts were in sharp focus. "It means they knew they were going to let us go . . . because when was that?"

"A few months ago."

"They wanted someone here in place to watch him . . . or us."

What if there were more like her?

What if someone closer to her was also watching her?

What if they all had someone watching?

How long had her mother known Steve again?

How long had Adam's family had that housekeeper?

What if Kristen's hypnotist was somehow . . . ?

"The other day," Ryan said. "Wow. When we were looking at photos. She knew our dog's name but I couldn't think of a time I'd ever told her we'd even had a dog."

"I'm so sorry, Ryan."

"She called him Luke the other day, too. He didn't seem to notice, but-it seemed weird." Ryan got up and took off down the hall. "She keeps some stuff here."

Scarlett followed him, but by the time she got down to the door of his bedroom, he was already coming back out.

"She's gone." He ran his hands through his hair and let out a guttur al moan. "All her stuff is gone."

The phone on the coffee table buzzed.

"Is that yours?" she asked when he didn't move for it.

"Lucas's. He left it in my car."

She slid down onto the couch under the weight of exhaustion. "She saw my texts. She knows we know."

Lucas

He'd fallen asleep against his will and now struggled to rouse himself in the bedroom compartment. Then heard movement in the RV's main room and grabbed an empty bottle by the neck. Moving quietly toward the hallway, he then burst into the other room with a loud "Who's there?"

Avery.

The relief he felt at seeing her caught him off guard. He dropped the bottle. He wanted to rush to her, take her in his arms, inhale the chlorine and honeysuckle of her hair. He wanted to pretend he'd never told her he couldn't be with her.

"You're out?" She shook her head. "Obviously." She stood. "I don't understand. I should go."

"Avery, wait." He grabbed her by the arm and stood in front of her. "I didn't kill John Norton. And I know what crazy theories are being thrown around, but I didn't kill anyone."

"But you can't prove it." She sounded equal parts sad and mad. Was there a word for that?

"Can't prove that I'm a good person?" He looked around like the proof might be there, in his father's writing on the walls. "No, but who can? Can you? I was wrong, Avery. You do know me." He stepped closer, stood right up against her the way she had with him on the lanai, when it had been all he could do to pull his body away from hers, like she'd been magnetized.

"I don't." She backed away, clearly not feeling the same pull.

"You do." Moving closer still, but then backing away, giving her s.p.a.ce. "And I'm going to go through everything in here again and I'm not going to stop until I get to the truth and find Max."

"You sound like your father," she said, not in a kind way.

"Good!"

"Everyone thought he was crazy."

"Maybe I am, too. It doesn't matter." This was wasting time. "You can help me or you can leave."

He'd brought his father's laptop out here and now sat down at the desk to get to work, going through every file in a folder marked "Videos." He heard her leave and had to stop himself from going after her. But then the door clicked open again and the floor creaked under her as she sat beside him. He took her hand, squeezed, then released.

They sifted through pages and pages of notes while playing videos of anniversary vigils and more. Most of the notes had been transferred to the whiteboards, and many of the news reports were repet.i.tive, nothing actually new in the news. No connection to the shooting that they could directly see.

They went backward chronologically, working their way through the clips, one after the other, occasionally pausing to study a face-"Cham bers was so young," Lucas said; "My mother loses it during this one," Avery said-then moving on.

Finally, they were back to the night of the day it had happened, the first national report. Watching it, Lucas felt panic, like he was back there, reliving the whole thing as a kid but not as one of the missing kids. What must it have felt like for Ryan? And for Avery. Not having any idea what was going on. Being shoved away from TVs and pushed out of rooms while her parents spent hours on the phone and crying.

And his father? What had gone through his head before he'd picked up a chisel and stone and committed himself to someday uncovering the truth?

"Chambers and the memory specialist are working this theory that what happened to us has to do with the shooting. Like trying to erase the memory of that."

"That's why they were asking if Max was there?"

"Yes."

The next clip played. A woman holding a girl toddler. The toddler holding a stuffed dog. She wore pajamas; she looked cold.

"That's me," Avery said.

And the whole scene came into focus alongside Lucas's feelings for Avery.

"I could only ever bring myself to watch this one once," she said. "Years ago."

"I'm sorry." Lucas paused it. "We can stop."

"No." She leaned closer, to study her own image. "It's okay."

He slid his arm around the back of her chair.

"It's so weird." She shook her head. "I can't believe that was ever . . . me. That I was ever that small. And just, like, clinging to my mother like that. And Woof-Woof-the dog-it's just so . . . different, I guess. It all went away that night."

"We really don't have to watch." He started to navigate away.

"Play it." She nodded, and leaned back into her chair, into his arm. He felt the connection like a lifeline.

A reporter shouts out, "Has the school made an official statement? Has the bus been traced?"

Another man steps up to the mike. "We're doing everything we can to help with the investigation. We have every expectation that the children will be returned safely."

"Everyone looks so naive," Lucas said. "They had no idea what was actually happening."

Avery's whole body stiffened, cold like a corpse, and he couldn't think of what he'd said wrong. "Avery, are you-"