Nasuada pursed her lips. "Of course I do, Eragon. I-" She looked off to the side of the image and listened as a man addressed her, his voice an unintelligible murmur to Eragon and Saphira. Returning her attention to them, Nasuada said, "Captain Edric's company has just returned. They appear to have suffered heavy casualties, but our watchmen say that Roran survived."

"Was he injured?" asked Eragon.

"I'll let you know once I find out. I would not worry too much, though. Roran has the luck of-" Once again, the voice of an unseen person distracted Nasuada, and she stepped out of view.

Eragon fidgeted while he waited.

"My apologies," said Nasuada, her visage reappearing in the basin. "We are closing in on Feinster, and we are having to fight off marauding groups of soldiers Lady Lorana sends from the city to hara.s.s us. . . . Eragon, Saphira, we need you for this battle. If the people of Feinster see only men, dwarves, and Urgals gathered outside their walls, they may believe they have a chance of holding the city, and they will fight all the harder because of it. They can't hold Feinster, of course, but they have yet to realize that. If they see a dragon and Rider leading the charges against them, however, they will lose the will to fight."

"But-"

Nasuada raised her hand, cutting him off. "There are other reasons for you to return as well. Because of my wounds from the Trial of the Long Knives, I cannot ride into battle with the Varden, as I have before. I need you you to take my place, Eragon, in order to see that my commands are carried out as I intend and also to prop up the spirits of our warriors. What's more, rumors of your absence are already coursing through the camp, despite our best efforts to the contrary. If Murtagh and Thorn attack us directly as a result, or if Galbatorix sends them to reinforce Feinster . . . well, even with the elves by our sides, I doubt we could withstand them. I'm sorry, Eragon, but I cannot allow you to return to Ellesmera right now. It's too dangerous." to take my place, Eragon, in order to see that my commands are carried out as I intend and also to prop up the spirits of our warriors. What's more, rumors of your absence are already coursing through the camp, despite our best efforts to the contrary. If Murtagh and Thorn attack us directly as a result, or if Galbatorix sends them to reinforce Feinster . . . well, even with the elves by our sides, I doubt we could withstand them. I'm sorry, Eragon, but I cannot allow you to return to Ellesmera right now. It's too dangerous."

Pressing his hands against the edge of the cold stone table upon which the basin rested, Eragon said, "Nasuada, please. If not now, then when?"

"Soon. You must be patient."

"Soon." Eragon drew a deep breath, tightening his grip on the table. "How soon exactly?"

Nasuada frowned at him. "You cannot expect me to know that. First we must take Feinster, and then we must secure the countryside, and then-"

"And then you intend to march on Belatona or Dras-Leona, and then to Uru'baen," said Eragon. Nasuada attempted to reply, but he did not allow her the opportunity. "And the closer you get to Galbatorix, the likelier it will be that Murtagh and Thorn will attack you, or even the king himself, and you will be ever more reluctant to let us go. . . . Nasuada, Saphira and I do not have the skill, the knowledge, nor the strength to kill Galbatorix. You know that! Galbatorix could end this war at any time if he was willing to leave his castle and confront the Varden directly. We have have to talk with our teachers again. They can tell us where Galbatorix's power is coming from, and they might be able to show us a trick or two that will allow us to defeat him." to talk with our teachers again. They can tell us where Galbatorix's power is coming from, and they might be able to show us a trick or two that will allow us to defeat him."

Nasuada gazed downward, studying her hands. "Thorn and Murtagh could destroy us while you were gone."

"And if we do not go, Galbatorix will destroy us when we reach Uru'baen. . . . Could you wait a few days before you attack Feinster?"

"We could, but every day we camp outside the city will cost us lives." Nasuada rubbed her temples with the heels of her palms. "You are asking a lot in exchange for an uncertain reward, Eragon."

"The reward may be uncertain," he said, "but our doom is inevitable unless we try."

"Is it? I am not so sure. Still . . ." For an uncomfortably long time, Nasuada was silent, gazing past the edge of the image. Then she nodded once, as if confirming something to herself, and said, "I can delay our arrival at Feinster for two or three days. There are several towns in the area we can seize first. Once we do reach the city, I can pa.s.s another two or three days having the Varden build siege engines and prepare fortifications. No one will think strangely of it. After that, though, I will have to set upon Feinster, if for no other reason but that we need their supplies. An army that sits still in enemy territory is an army that starves. At the most, I can give you six days, and perhaps only four."

As she spoke, Eragon made several quick calculations. "Four days won't be long enough," he said, "and six might not be either. It took Saphira three days to fly to Farthen Dur, and that was without stopping to sleep and without having to carry my weight. If the maps I have seen are accurate, it's at least as far from here to Ellesmera, maybe farther, and about the same from Ellesmera to Feinster. And with me on her back, Saphira won't be able to cover the distance as quickly."

No, I won't, Saphira said to him. Saphira said to him.

Eragon continued: "Even under the best of circ.u.mstances, it would still take us a week to reach you at Feinster, and that would be without staying for more than a minute in Ellesmera."

An expression of profound exhaustion crossed Nasuada's face. "Must you fly all the way to Ellesmera? Wouldn't it be sufficient to scry with your mentors once you are past the wards along the edge of Du Weldenvarden? The time you would save could be crucial."

"I don't know. We can try."

Nasuada closed her eyes for a moment. In a hoa.r.s.e voice, she said, "I may be able to delay our arrival at Feinster for four days. . . . Go to Ellesmera or don't; I leave the decision up to you. If you do, then stay however long is needed. You're right; unless you find a way to defeat Galbatorix, we have no hope of victory. Even so, keep you in mind the tremendous risk we are taking, the lives of the Varden I will be sacrificing in order to buy you this time, and how many more of the Varden will die if we lay siege to Feinster without you."

Somber, Eragon nodded. "I won't forget."

"I should hope not. Now go! Do not tarry any longer! Fly. Fly! Fly faster than a diving hawk, Saphira, and do not let anything slow you." Nasuada touched the tips of her fingers to her lips and then pressed them against the invisible surface of the mirror, where he knew she beheld the moving likeness of him and Saphira. "Luck on your journey, Eragon, Saphira. If we meet again, I fear it will be on the field of battle."

And then she hurried from their sight, and Eragon released his spell, and the water in the basin cleared.

THE W WHIPPING P POST Roran sat bolt upright and stared past Nasuada, his eyes fixed upon a wrinkle in the side of the crimson pavilion.

He could feel Nasuada studying him, but he refused to meet her gaze. During the long, dull silence that enveloped them, he contemplated a host of dire possibilities, and his temples throbbed with a feverish intensity. He wished he could leave the stifling pavilion and breathe the cool air outside.

At last Nasuada said, "What am I going to do with you, Roran?"

He straightened his spine even more. "Whatever you wish, my Lady."

"An admirable answer, Stronghammer, but in no way does it resolve my quandary." Nasuada sipped wine from a goblet. "Twice you defied a direct order from Captain Edric, and yet if you hadn't, neither he nor you nor the rest of your band might have survived to tell the tale. However, your success does not negate the reality of your disobedience. By your own account, you knowingly committed insubordination, and I must must punish you if I am to maintain discipline among the Varden." punish you if I am to maintain discipline among the Varden."

"Yes, my Lady."

Her brow darkened. "Blast it, Stronghammer. If you were anyone else but Eragon's cousin, and if your gambit had been even one whit less effective, I would have you strung up and hanged for your misconduct."

Roran swallowed as he imagined a noose tightening around his neck.

With the middle finger of her right hand, Nasuada tapped the arm of her high-backed chair with increasing speed until, stopping, she said, "Do you wish to continue fighting with the Varden, Roran?"

"Yes, my Lady," he replied without hesitation.

"What are you willing to endure in order to remain within my army?"

Roran did not allow himself to dwell upon the implications of her question. "Whatever I must, my Lady."

The tension in her face eased, and Nasuada nodded, appearing satisfied. "I hoped you would say that. Tradition and established precedent leave me only three choices. One, I can hang you, but I won't . . . for a mult.i.tude of reasons. Two, I can give you thirty lashes and then discharge you from the ranks of the Varden. Or three, I can give you fifty lashes and keep you under my command."

Fifty lashes isn't that many more than thirty, Roran thought, trying to bolster his courage. He wet his lips. "Would I be flogged where all could see?" Roran thought, trying to bolster his courage. He wet his lips. "Would I be flogged where all could see?"

Nasuada's eyebrows rose a fraction of an inch. "Your pride has no part in this, Stronghammer. The punishment must be severe so that others are not tempted to follow in your footsteps, and it must be held in public so that the whole of the Varden can profit by it. If you are even half as intelligent as you seem, you knew when you defied Edric that your decision would have consequences and that those consequences would most likely be unpleasant. The choice you must now make is simple: will you stay with the Varden, or will you abandon your friends and family and go your own way?"

Roran lifted his chin, angry that she would question his word. "I shall not leave, Lady Nasuada. No matter how many lashes you a.s.sign me, they cannot be as painful as losing my home and my father was."

"No," said Nasuada softly. "They could not. . . . One of the magicians of Du Vrangr Gata will oversee the flogging and attend to you afterward, to ensure that the whip causes you no permanent damage. However, they shall not entirely heal your wounds, nor may you seek out a magician on your own to mend your back."

"I understand."

"Your flogging will be held as soon as Jormundur can marshal the troops. Until then, you will remain under guard in a tent by the whipping post."

It relieved Roran that he would not have to wait any longer; he did not want to have to labor for days under the shadow of what lay before him. "My Lady," he said, and she dismissed him with a motion of her finger.

Turning on his heel, Roran marched out of the pavilion. Two guards took up positions on either side of him as he emerged. Without looking at or speaking to him, they led Roran through the camp until they arrived at a small, empty tent not far from the blackened whipping post, which stood upon a slight rise just beyond the edge of the camp.

The post was six and a half feet high and had a thick crossbeam near the top, to which prisoners' wrists were tied. Rows of scratches from the fingernails of scourged men covered the crossbeam.

Roran forced himself to look away and then ducked inside the tent. The only piece of furniture inside was a battered wooden stool. He sat and concentrated upon his breathing, determined to remain calm.

As the minutes pa.s.sed, Roran began to hear the tromp of boots and the clink of mail as the Varden a.s.sembled around the whipping post. Roran imagined the thousands of men and women staring at him, including the villagers from Carvahall. His pulse quickened, and sweat sprang up upon his brow.

After about half an hour, the sorceress Trianna entered the tent and had him strip down to his trousers, which embarra.s.sed Roran, although the woman seemed to take no notice. Trianna examined him all over, and even cast an additional spell of healing on his left shoulder, where the soldier had stabbed him with the bolt of a crossbow. Then she declared him fit to continue and gave him a shirt made of sackcloth to wear in place of his own.

Roran had just pulled the shirt over his head when Katrina pushed her way into the tent. As he beheld her, an equal measure of joy and dread filled Roran.

Katrina glanced between him and Trianna, then curtsied to the sorceress. "May I please speak with my husband alone?"

"Of course. I shall wait outside."

Once Trianna had departed, Katrina rushed to Roran and threw her arms around him. He hugged her just as fiercely as she hugged him, for he had not seen her since he had returned to the Varden.

"Oh, how I've missed you," Katrina whispered in his right ear.

"And I you," he murmured.

They drew apart just far enough so that they could gaze into each other's eyes, and then Katrina scowled. "This is wrong! I went to Nasuada, and I begged her to pardon you, or at least to reduce the number of lashes, but she refused to grant my request."

Running his hands up and down Katrina's back, Roran said, "I wish that you hadn't."

"Why not?"

"Because I said that I would remain with the Varden, and I will not go back on my word."

"But this is wrong!" said Katrina, gripping him by his shoulders. "Carn told me what you did, Roran: you slew almost two hundred soldiers by yourself, and if not for your heroism, none of the men with you would have survived. Nasuada ought to be plying you with gifts and praise, not having you whipped like a common criminal!"

"It does not matter whether this is right or wrong," he told her. "It is necessary. If I were in Nasuada's position, I would have given the same order myself."

Katrina shuddered. "Fifty lashes, though. . . . Why does it have to be so many? Men have died from being whipped that many times."

"Only if they had weak hearts. Don't be so worried; it will take more than that to kill me."

A false smile flickered across Katrina's lips, and then a sob escaped her and she pressed her face against his chest. He cradled her in his arms, stroking her hair and rea.s.suring her as best he could, even though he felt no better than she. After several minutes, Roran heard a horn being winded outside the tent, and he knew that their time together was drawing to a close. Extricating himself from Katrina's embrace, he said, "There is something I want you to do for me."

"What?" she asked, dabbing at her eyes.

"Go back to our tent and do not leave it until after my flogging."

Katrina appeared shocked by his request. "No! I shall not leave you . . . not now."

"Please," he said, "you should not have to see this."

"And you should not have to endure it," she retorted.

"Leave that. I know you wish to stay by my side, but I can bear this better if I know that you aren't here watching me. . . . I brought this upon myself, Katrina, and I do not want you to suffer because of it as well."

Her expression became strained. "The knowledge of your fate shall pain me regardless of where I am standing. However . . . I shall do as you ask, but only because it will help you through this ordeal. . . . You know that I would have the whip fall upon my own body instead of yours, if I could."

"And you know," he said, kissing her on both cheeks, "that I would refuse to let you take my place."

Tears welled up in her eyes again, and she pulled him closer, hugging him so tightly, he had difficulty breathing.

They were still wrapped in each other's arms when the entrance flap to the tent was swept back and Jormundur entered, along with two of the Nighthawks. Katrina disengaged herself from Roran, curtsied to Jormundur, and then, without a word, slipped out of the tent.

Jormundur extended a hand toward Roran. "It's time."

Nodding, Roran rose and allowed Jormundur and the guards to escort him to the whipping post outside. Row after row of the Varden boxed in the area around the post, every man, woman, dwarf, and Urgal standing with stiff spines and squared shoulders. After his initial glimpse of the a.s.sembled army, Roran gazed off toward the horizon and did his best to ignore the onlookers.

The two guards lifted Roran's arms above his head and secured his wrists to the crossbeam of the whipping post. While they did, Jormundur walked around in front of the post and held up a leather-wrapped dowel. "Here, bite down on this," he said in a low voice. "It will keep you from hurting yourself." Grateful, Roran opened his mouth and allowed Jormundur to fit the dowel between his teeth. The tanned leather tasted bitter, like green acorns.

Then a horn and a drumroll sounded, and Jormundur read out the charges against Roran, and the guards cut off Roran's sackcloth shirt.

He shivered as the cold air washed across his bare torso.

An instant before it struck, Roran heard the whip whistling through the air.

It felt as if a rod of hot metal had been laid across his flesh. Roran arched his back and bit down on the dowel. An involuntary groan escaped him, although the dowel m.u.f.fled the sound so he thought no one else heard.

"One," said the man wielding the whip.

The shock of the second blow caused Roran to groan again, but thereafter he remained silent, determined not to appear weak before the whole of the Varden.

The whipping was as painful as any of the numerous wounds Roran had suffered over the past few months, but after a dozen or so blows, he gave up trying to fight the pain and, surrendering to it, entered a bleary trance. His field of vision narrowed until the only thing he saw was the worn wood in front of him; at times, his sight flickered and went blank as he drifted into brief spates of unconsciousness.

After an interminable time, he heard the dim and faraway voice intone, "Thirty," and despair gripped him as he wondered, How can I possibly withstand another twenty lashes? How can I possibly withstand another twenty lashes? Then he thought of Katrina and their unborn child, and the thought gave him strength. Then he thought of Katrina and their unborn child, and the thought gave him strength.

Roran woke to find himself lying on his stomach on the cot inside the tent he and Katrina shared. Katrina was kneeling next to him, stroking his hair and murmuring in his ear, while someone daubed a cold, sticky substance over the stripes on his back. He winced and stiffened as the anonymous person poked a particularly sensitive spot.

"That is not not how I would treat a patient of mine," he heard Trianna say in a haughty tone. how I would treat a patient of mine," he heard Trianna say in a haughty tone.

"If you treat all of your patients as you were treating Roran," another woman replied, "I'm amazed that any survived your attentions." After a moment, Roran recognized the second voice as belonging to the strange, bright-eyed herbalist Angela.

"I beg your pardon!" said Trianna. "I will not stand here and be insulted by a lowly fortuneteller fortuneteller who struggles to cast even the most basic spell." who struggles to cast even the most basic spell."

"Sit, then, if it pleases you, but whether you sit or stand, I will continue to insult you until you admit that his back muscle attaches here here and not and not there there." Roran felt a finger touch him in two different places, each a half inch apart.

"Oh!" said Trianna, and left the tent.

Katrina smiled at Roran, and for the first time, he noticed the tears streaking her face. "Roran, do you understand me?" she asked. "Are you awake?"

"I . . . I think so," he said, his voice raspy. His jaw ached from biting the dowel so hard for so long. He coughed, then grimaced as every one of the fifty stripes on his back throbbed in unison.