_Neuralgia._ _Myalgia._

Follows the distribution of a Attacks a limited patch or recognizable nerve or nerves. patches that can be identified with the tendon or aponeurosis of a muscle which, on inquiry, will be found to have been hardly worked.

Goes along with an inherited or As often as not occurs in persons acquired nervous temperament, with no special neurotic which is obvious. tendency.

Is much less aggravated, Is inevitably, and very severely, usually, by movement than aggravated by every movement of myalgia is. the part.

Is at first accompanied by no Distinguished from the first, by local tenderness. localized tenderness on pressure as well as on movement.

Points douloureux, when Tender points correspond to established at a later stage, tendinous origins and insertions correspond to the emergence of of muscles.

nerves.

Pain not materially relieved by Pain usually completely and always any change of posture. considerably relieved by full extension of the painful muscle or muscles.

The treatment of myalgia is not only satisfactory in itself, but often affords, in its results, a very desirable confirmation of diagnosis.

For a very large number of cases, all that is required is (_a_) to put and keep the affected muscle in a position of full extension, which is only to be changed at somewhat rare intervals; (_b_) to cover the skin all over and round it with spongio-piline, so as to maintain a perpetual vapor-bath; (_c_) on the subsidence of the acutest pain and tenderness, to complete the treatment by one or two Turkish baths, to be taken in the manner that I have recommended by speaking of the prophylaxis of neuralgia.

When treatment such as this cures a pain which was greatly aggravated by muscular movement, we may be sure that pain was myalgic and not neuralgic.

The pain, however, is not unfrequently rebellious to such simple remedies as these, more especially when (as in pleurodynia) we are not able to enforce complete physiological rest of the part. When this is the case, we shall find the internal use of twenty and thirty grain doses of muriate of ammonia by far the most effective remedy. In the first very acute stage of a severe case it may be advisable to inject morphia hypodermically; but this is seldom necessary. The muriate-of-ammonia treatment may be usefully accompanied by prolonged gentle frictions, three or four times a day, with a weak chloroform liniment.

When there is visibly a very great deficiency in the general nutrition, we shall often fail to obtain a cure until we have remedied this defect; and accordingly, in the majority of cases of half-starved and overworked needle-women, cobblers, tailors, and the like, who present themselves in the out-patient room, I accompany the above-named treatment with the steady administration of cod-liver oil for three or four weeks or more.

There is one remedy for this pain which I have myself seen used in only a few cases, but which I believe promises exceedingly well for the treatment of obstinate myalgia; viz., acupuncture. I have not even mentioned it as a remedy for neuralgia, for I believe it to be totally useless in true cases of that disease, whether applied in the simple form or in that of galvano-puncture. I think very differently of its use in myalgia; and I venture to believe that it is entirely to cases of this disease that the exceedingly interesting observations of Mr. T. P.

Teale, in a recent number of the _Lancet_, apply. Where (after the usual remedies for myalgia have been applied) we are unable to get rid of a deep-seated and fixed muscular pain, I believe it to be excellent practice to plunge two or three long needles deeply into the muscle near its tendinous attachment.

CHAPTER II.

SPINAL IRRITATION.

I retain this phrase, not because it is an absolutely good one, but because it has become so familiar that it is difficult to dispense with it. We have taken a useful step, however, in separating the true neuralgias from the somewhat indefinite group of diseases to which this t.i.tle has been given. I think the reader who has carefully studied Part I. of this work will not deny that the latter disorders present a very clear and definite common outline which distinguishes them essentially from the vaguer affections to be described under the present heading.

Spinal irritation, in my sense, includes all those conditions in which, without any special mental affection, and without any single nerve being definitely affected, there are sensations varying between mere cutaneous tenderness, often of a large and irregular surface, and acute pain approaching neuralgia in character, together with fixed tenderness of certain vertebrae on deep pressure. A very large majority of the phenomena are such as would be popularly included (now that they are known not to be of an inflammatory character) under the term "hysterical." That unhappy word crosses our path at every turn in a most embarra.s.sing manner, and yet it can hardly at present be said that we could afford to do without it.

The more typical cases of so-called "hysterical hyperaesthesia" present the following phenomena: Along with the general symptoms of the hysterical temperament (tendency to causeless depression, variable spirits, sensation of globus, semi-convulsive attacks terminated by the discharge of a great quant.i.ty of pale, limpid urine) there is commonly a marked superficial tenderness of the surface everywhere, and an exaggeration of reflex irritability. The general tenderness is so far merely cutaneous that deep pressure is ordinarily borne better than the lightest finger-touch. But besides this there are usually one or several spots in which the tenderness is more profound and genuine. There is almost sure to be some point in the spinal column where firm pressure not merely evokes a complaint of pain, but also induces secondary objective phenomena connected with distant organs, such as nausea and vomiting when the cervical vertebrae are tender, severe gastric pain when the dorsal vertebrae are tender, etc. In such cases there is not only spinal tenderness, but very usually also a well-marked tenderness in the epigastrium and the left hypochondrium, the _trepied hysterique_ of Briquet. The reader must, however, be warned that the whole of these three tender points may be merely myalgic, and it is necessary very carefully to observe whether local movements do or do not seriously aggravate the pain in them. And, on the other hand, the spinal tender point may be merely the "point apophysaire" of a true neuralgia which exhibits no other symptoms of the so-called hysteric const.i.tution.

The kind of hysteria that is joined with the existence of fixed tender spots in definite points of the vertebral column is not commonly distinguished by the occurrence of cutaneous anaesthesia; but those writers are certainly wrong in saying that such a combination never takes place. I have seen examples of the most marked union of the two cla.s.ses of symptoms in the same person.

These cases of so-called spinal irritation with general hysteric manifestations are very commonly attended with paroxysmal pains that approach true neuralgia in character. Nor is it to be denied that we sometimes meet with the combination of general hysteria, spinal tenderness in definite points (with secondary spasmodic or paralytic phenomena always following pressure exerted on the latter), and true neuralgia limited to one nerve. But the more typical spinal irritation cases are merely complicated with a tendency to vague pains which are shifting both in character and position, not with definite unilateral neuralgia always haunting the same nerve and exhibiting more or less of the same type. In fact, as far as one can judge in the absence of any precise information as to the condition of the nervous centres in such cases, it would seem likely that the ordinary cases of spinal irritation differ from the true neuralgias chiefly in this--that the injury, or inherited weakness of organization, or both, which is at the root of the malady, is at once slighter in degree, and spread over a larger tract of the nervous centres, than that which produces a true neuralgia. I believe that Dr. Radcliffe is right in supposing it to be probable that a blow or other injury to the back producing general spinal shock, is the original but unsuspected cause of a large proportion of these cases.

One of the most perfect examples of spinal irritation that I have ever seen (and which also contrasts keenly with the commoner hysteric affections on the one hand, and the true neuralgiae on the other) was that of a girl whom I examined together with Dr. Walshe, Dr. Reynolds, and Dr. Bridge. This young lady was a most intelligent person, and not in the slightest degree inclined to the apathy and idleness so often seen in hysterical people. She had received what was thought at the time to be a very slight contusion in a railway collision, in which, however, her sister, who was in the same carriage, had been severely injured. She nursed this sister a.s.siduously, and it was not till three or four months later that her own health began to fail seriously; but she then became anaemic and extremely depressed. About six months after the accident it was quite casually discovered that there was a spot over the lowest cervical vertebra, pressure on which gave her exquisite pain and a sensation of extreme nausea; and the very curious observation was made that such pressure instantaneously produced extinction of the right pulse, the left pulse remaining unaltered. In this case it cannot be doubted that a serious shock had been communicated to a lateral segment of the cord involving chiefly the vaso-motor nerve fibres, in which probably some decided material lesion had been gradually set up; and besides this there was probably slighter damage to the spinal cord generally, as there was great general feebleness of movement, though no actual paralysis of the limbs.

Along with the phenomena of fixed spinal tenderness, without distinct neuralgia of any particular nerve, we not unfrequently observe the development of more or less decided tenderness of some of the internal surfaces of the body. I have recently had under my care a young woman in whom a very tender point was developed over the second cervical vertebra, and who suffered from such persistent tenderness of the whole posterior part of the pharynx, that I was for some time seriously apprehensive of the existence of spinal caries and post-pharyngeal abscess. The general character of her symptoms, however, induced me to hope that the case was one of spinal irritation merely, and the event proved that this was the case, for under the use of iron and small doses of strychnia she recovered completely in about three weeks. In another patient who came under my care about twelve months ago, there was extraordinary sensitiveness of the gastric mucous membrane, causing exquisite pain after she had eaten almost any thing: there was only occasional vomiting, however, and there had never been any haemorrhage, so that the evidence for gastric ulcer, which I otherwise inclined to think existed, was insufficient. I discovered that pressure on the third or the fourth dorsal vertebra gave great pain, and produced a strong inclination to vomit; this made it probable that the affection was spinal, and accordingly all treatment addressed to the stomach was abandoned. Flying blisters to the neighborhood of the painful spinal points quickly relieved all the symptoms.

Another distressing cla.s.s of symptoms, which is very commonly observed in connection with these cases of spinal irritation, is that of abnormal arterial pulsations: I am not sure whether even severe neuralgia produces more distress than does this pulsation. I have repeatedly seen abnormal pulsation of the carotids in connection with fixed tender-points over the cervical or the upper dorsal vertebrae; and still more commonly pulsation of the abdominal aorta in connection with tenderness over one or two of the upper dorsal vertebrae. Spasmodic cough and spasmodic dyspnoea frequently accompany tenderness of points in the upper half of the spinal column; and in one instance I have seen pressure on the lowest cervical vertebrae produce a paroxysm which looked alarmingly like angina pectoris. A case of singularly prolonged and obstinate spasmodic hiccough which came under my notice was distinguished by the presence of a fixed tender spot over the third dorsal vertebra.

Prolonged spastic contraction of voluntary muscles, going on, sometimes for weeks, and even months, is a phenomenon that has often been observed; it may attack the arm only, or may affect all the limbs, and the muscles of the trunk and of the neck: it is for the most part symmetrical, but is occasionally unilateral. It begins in the extremities, and is very commonly limited to them; it is much more gentle than tetanic spasm, and is also painless, or nearly so; but the contraction is often strong enough to resist very vigorous efforts at artificial extension.

Paralyses, both of bowel and bladder, have been recorded among the occasional phenomena of spinal irritation with fixed tender points; but I cannot say that I have ever seen such an occurrence. On the whole, I must say that by far the most frequent phenomena of spinal irritation that I have seen have been somewhat diffuse cutaneous or mucous tenderness and irritability (without acute pain) and the presence of tormenting arterial throbbings; also a marked tendency to aggravation of some symptoms, especially the gastric, when firm pressure is made upon the tender spinal points. For a further and fuller account of the phenomena of spinal irritation I may refer the reader to the able article of Dr. Radcliffe,[48] and the work of the brothers Griffin, already quoted; adding the suggestion, however, that both these authorities, and especially the Griffins, appear to me not to draw a sufficiently clear distinction between the cla.s.s of cases that I have been attempting to describe and the true neuralgias.

After what has been said, there is no need to draw out a formal list of the points of diagnosis between spinal irritation and neuralgia. It must be admitted, moreover, that the two forms of diseases have a strong connection in the fact that they are each of them most frequently developed in the descendants of neurotic families. It is by the more generalized character of the symptoms, and the absence of the tendency to perpetual recurrence of paroxysmal pain in one definite nerve, that spinal irritation is mainly distinguishable from true neuralgia. I may add that there is a marked distinction, also, in the results of treatment.

The treatment of spinal irritation is, it must be confessed still in an unsatisfactory position; and I believe that a good deal of unnecessary discouragement has been occasioned to physicians by their failures to cure supposed neuralgias which really belonged to the spinal irritation cla.s.s. I would a.s.suredly by no means a.s.sert that genuine neuralgia is not frequently intractable, or even incurable; but it is certainly much more curable than spinal irritation; and for this reason, mainly as I believe--that there is much more possibility of aiming our remedies at the actual seat of the disease. On the other hand, in spinal irritation we are confused and distracted with a variety of phenomena for which even the most subtle a.n.a.lysis will frequently fail to trace a common origin. It is true that the existence of definite tender spots in the spine apparently suggests a strictly local application of remedies; and it true also that medication based upon this fact is sometimes very effective; but this is, in my experience, only an occasional result, and the pract.i.tioner who trusts to local measures will frequently be disappointed. And, on the other hand, the general tonic treatment, and the use of special medicines, like quinine and a.r.s.enic, or the hypodermic injection of morphia oratropia, have nothing like the extensive utility in the treatment of spinal irritation that they possess in that of true neuralgia. Of internal remedies, by far the most useful in my hands have been sesquichloride of iron with small doses of strychnia, and the milder vegetable bitters, especially calumba.

There is one special phase, however, of spinal irritation which is very amenable to the direct, treatment, viz., cutaneous and mucous tenderness. Whatever the "hyperaesthetic" part is within reach, so that we can apply Faradization, we can almost certainly eradicate the morbid sensibility very quickly. The secondary current of an electro-magnetic or volta-electric induction apparatus is to be employed; the conductors should be of dry metal and the negative one, which is to be applied to the painful surface, should be in the form of the wire brush. The positive pole is to be placed on some indifferent spot, and the negative is to be stroked briskly backward and forward over the sensitive skin, a pretty strong current being employed. The process is painful so much so that it will often be advisable, with delicate patients, either to administer chloroform or to inject morphia subcutaneously before the Faradization. A very few daily sittings of four or five minutes length will generally remove the morbid tenderness completely. Where the tender part is within one of the cavities, at the r.e.c.t.u.m, bladder, v.a.g.i.n.a, or pharynx, we must of course use a solid negative conductor of appropriate form, and must content ourselves with applying it steadily to one point after another of the sensitive surface.

The fact that Faradization proves so remarkably useful, in these cases of spinal irritation with diffuse cutaneous or mucous tenderness, is in itself a strong diagnostic between this sort of affection and the true neuralgiae, which, as I have stated are seldom benefited, and are often made worse, by the interrupted current, though the constant current frequently mitigates or cures them.

Sometimes where it is not possible to apply the remedy directly to the sensitive surface, we may nevertheless do great good by sending the interrupted current through it. Thus, in gastric sensitiveness connected with spinal tenderness in the upper dorsal region, I have seen very great relief afforded by sending a current from the positive pole, placed on the tender vertebrae, to a broad, negative conductor placed on the epigastrium. And similarly, I have seen an acutely sensitive condition of the neck of the bladder greatly soothed by the pa.s.sage of a current from a painful lumbar vertebra to the perinaeum immediately behind the s.c.r.o.t.u.m.

Undoubtedly, however, the more serious cases of spinal irritation will yield only (if they yield at all) to a prolonged treatment in which very skilful use is made of general hygienic measures, and especially of morbal influences. As the brothers Griffin long ago pointed out, although rest is useful in the early stages of this malady, if the disease does not quickly yield to this and to appropriate tonic medication, and perhaps local applications to the spine, it will not do to keep the patient rec.u.mbent and confined to the house; on the contrary at whatever cost of immediate discomfort, he (or she for these patients are by far the most frequently females) must be roused up, and persuaded or compelled to take out-door exercise, and if possible to travel, and divert the mind by complete change of scene. When such expensive remedies are out of the question, it seems better that patients, even seemingly very feeble, should take to their ordinary avocations in life again, and fight down the tendency to invalidism. But of course, the decision on such a point must rest with the tact and judgment of the pract.i.tioner in each individual case, for there are, doubtless, instances in which the attempt to carry out such a plan, even moderately, would break down the remaining strength, and make matters worse than they were before.

In the worse case of spinal irritation that I ever saw, that of a young lady, aged twenty-eight, there were p.r.o.nounced anaemia and general feebleness, the true hysteric _trepied_ of tender points, painful irritability of the stomach, which baffled all medical advisers and resisted almost every possible form of tonic and nervine medicines, counter-irritation to the spine, and, in fact every thing that one dared attempt with so feeble-looking a patient, but at once cleared up and was quite cured after marriage. And there can be no question that a very large proportion of these cases in single women (who form by far the greater number of subjects of spinal irritation) are due to this conscious or unconscious irritation kept up by an unsatisfied s.e.xual want. In some patients there cannot be a doubt that this condition of things is indefinitely aggravated by the practice of self abuse; but it would be most unjust to think that this is a necessary element in the causation; on the contrary, it is certain that very many young persons (women more especially) are tormented by the irritability of the s.e.xual organs without having the least consciousness of sensual desire, and present the sad spectacle of a _vie manquee_ without ever knowing the true source of the misery which incapacitates them for all the active duties of life. It is a singular fact, that in occasional instances one may even see two sisters inheriting the same kind of nervous organization, both tormented with the symptoms of spinal irritation, and both probably suffering from repressed s.e.xual function, but of whom one shall be pure-minded and entirely unconscious of the real source of her troubles, while the other is a victim to conscious and fruitless s.e.xual irritation.

I have already causally alluded to the danger of mistaking mere myalgia for spinal irritation and must again enforce this consideration upon the reader. Myalgic tender points in the region of the spine are common enough; and it would be easy without careful attention, to mistake them for the deeper-seated vertebral tenderness which is truly characteristic of spinal irritation. Hence the utmost care must be taken to ascertain the true history of the commencement of the disorder whether it succeeded to great and long continued fatigue of particular sets of muscles, and whether it is specially aggravated by contractions of those muscles, and relieved by their full extension. The differences of treatment which depend on the diagnosis are too obvious to need dwelling upon.

The question of administering remedies with the direct intention of procuring sleep, for patients suffering from spinal irritation, often becomes an important and a very difficult one. It is, for the most part, highly objectionable to commence the use of such remedies; and yet sleeplessness is a very distressing symptom with many patients, and is, of course in itself exhausting and deleterious. For as long as we possibly can, we should content ourselves with efforts to produce sleep by the timely administration of nourishment. The same general rule of a very generous (though not very stimulating) diet to be enforced as carefully as in the case of sufferers from neuralgia. But it is especially advisable in spinal irritation; that the patient should take some food shortly before bedtime; and it is well, also to place food within reach at the bedside, so that if he wakes up he may take some.

If, however, we are absolutely driven to employ hypnotics, we must commence with the very mildest. The popular remedy of a pillow stuffed with hops will sometimes suffice; and a better way of administering the volatile principle of hops is to scatter a few hops on hot water in an inhaler, and let the patient breathe the steam. Hot foot-baths, with mustard, are also very useful. If these fail, chloral, in moderate doses is probably the best and safest remedy, and, with care not to give too much, we may go on using the same dose without increase for a good many times.

FOOTNOTE:

[48] Reynolds's "System of Medicine," vol. ii., Art. "Spinal Irritation."

CHAPTER III.

THE PAINS OF HYPOCHONDRIASIS.

There is perhaps nothing, in the whole range of practical medicine, more difficult to seize with clear comprehension, and picture to the mind with accuracy, than the group of pseudo-neuralgiae which belong to the domain of hypochondriasis. They are among the most indefinable, and at the same time the most intractable, of nervous affections.

To understand what hypochondriac pains are, we must first be familiar with the general character of the hypochondriacal temperament, for the pains are only a subordinate and ever-varying phenomena of the general disease.

Hypochondriasis is not insanity, if by insanity we mean intellectual perversion dependent mainly or entirely on the state of the higher nervous centres. But it is closely allied to insanity in its phenomena, only that these are, as it were, manifested in a scattered form, unequally distributed over the whole central nervous system, and especially affecting the spinal sensory centres. And its radical relationship to true insanity is strongly indicated by the fact that the sufferers from hypochondriasis are nearly, if not quite, always members of families in which distinct insanity has shown itself; indeed, more often than not, of families which have been strongly tainted in this way. In the majority of instances there are psychical peculiarities of a marked kind which accompany or precede the development of the abnormal sensations which form the especial torment of hypochondriacs. Without apparent cause, they begin to evince a heightened self-feeling and an anxious concentration of their thoughts upon the state of one or more of their bodily organs. Or it may be that, before any such definite bias is given to their thoughts, they simply become less sociable and more self-centred, and are subject to fits of indefinite and inexplicable depression, or at least to great variability of spirits. But before long they begin to experience definite morbid sensations, most commonly connected with the digestive organs, and very often accompanied by positive derangement of digestion of an objective character; such as flatulence, sour eructation, spasmodic stomach-pain, etc. Along with these phenomena, or soon afterward (and not unfrequently before the patient has acquired that intensity of morbid conviction of his having some special disease which is afterward so marked a peculiarity of his mental state), he very often becomes the subject of the kind of pains which it is the special purpose of this chapter to describe.

The pains of hypochondriasis, when they a.s.sume any more definite form than that of mere dyspeptic uneasiness, present many a.n.a.logies with neuralgia. They are not, usually, periodic in any regular manner, but they have the same tendency to complete intermission, and they frequently haunt some one or more definite nerves for a considerable period of time. Of all nerves that are liable to this kind of affections the vagus is undoubtedly the most susceptible; hypochondriac patients very frequently complain of pseudo-anginoid and pseudo-gastralgic pains; next in frequency are nervous pain in the region of the liver, or in the r.e.c.t.u.m or bladder. The main distinctions by which they are separable from true neuralgia are two: in the first place, the character of the pain nearly always is more of the boring or burning kind than of the acutely darting sort which is most usual in true neuralgia; and, secondly, the influence of mental attention in aggravating the pain is far more p.r.o.nounced than in the latter malady; indeed, it is often possible, by merely engaging the patient in conversation on other topics, to cause the pain to disappear altogether for the time. But in hypochondriasis it is not often that we are left, for any long time, to these means of diagnosis only; the special character of the disease is that the morbid sensations shift from one place to another, in a manner that is quite unlike that of the true neuralgias. The patient who to-day complains of the most severe gastralgia, or liver-pain, will to-morrow place all his sufferings in the cardiac region, or in the r.e.c.t.u.m, or will complain of a deep fixed pain within his head; and these changes are often most rapid and frequent. Frequently there are also peculiar skin sensations, which usually approach formication in type, and these, like the pains, are apt to shift with rapidity from one part of the body to another. Later on in the disease, especially in those worst cases which approach most closely to the type of true insanity, there are often hallucinations of a peculiar and characteristic nature, such as the conviction of the patient that he has some animal inside him gnawing his vitals, that he is made of gla.s.s and in constant danger of being broken, and a variety of similar absurdities. In short, it is not the fully-developed cases of hypochondriasis that need puzzle us, these are usually distinct enough; but the earlier and less characteristic stages in which pain may be nearly the only symptom that is particularly prominent.

In hypochondriasis, as in hysteria, there is often great sensitiveness of the surface; and, as in hysteria, this sensitiveness is found to be very superficial, so that a light touch often hurts more than firm, deep pressure. As in hysteria, too, the tenderness is a phenomenon so greatly affected by the mind, that, if we can divert the patient's attention for a moment, he will let us touch him anywhere, without noticing it at all.

It is a marked peculiarity of hypochondriasis that it is far more common in men than in women; a relation which is precisely the opposite to that which rules in neuralgia. Hypochondriasis is also pre-eminently a disease of adult middle life; it is scarcely ever seen in youth, except as the result of excessive masturbation acting on a temperament hereditarily predisposed to insanity.

The results of treatment frequently a.s.sist our diagnosis in difficult cases. Almost any medicine will relieve the pains of the hypochondriac for a time, and it is generally far easier to do him good, temporarily, than it is to relieve a neuralgic patient; but, _en revanche_, every remedy is apt to lose its affect after a little while. The only chance of producing permanent benefit in hypochondriasis is by the judicious combination of remedies that remove symptoms (especially dyspepsia, flatulence, etc.), which mischievously engage the patient's mind, with general tonics, and, above all, which such alterations in the patient's habits of daily life as take him out of himself and compel him to interest himself in the affairs of the world around him. And, after all, our best efforts will frequently lead to nothing but disappointment.