"You could have stayed-"

"He sent us-"

Moonlight and fear leached Colin's face of angles, of hollows, of the spirit that made him human. "We're to go home. He said so. He sent us back."

"And leave Robbie and Jamie behind?" Cat doubled up a fist and smacked him on the shoulder. "You muckle-mouthed coward, we're Campbells-" She looked beyond Dougal, beyond the scree, to the fire beyond, where she saw man-shaped shadows and the glint of a bared blade. "Campbells, ye ken-" She let loose the Campbell war cry in her deepest voice. "Chruachan!"

"Cat-Cat, no . . . dinna let them ken-" Dougal clutched her shoulder, pressing her toward her garron. "Go-"

"Let them ken!" she spat, twisting away. "Let them think we've more men than they . . ." Cat frowned. "How many? How many are they?"

Colin sucked a sc.r.a.ped thumb. "Ten," he said flatly, around the battered thumb.

"Four," Dougal declared.

"Ten, or four?" Scowling, Cat stared toward the fire again. Her scalp p.r.i.c.kled annoyingly beneath the bonnet; a grue coursed down her spine. She marked several shapes, but none of them stood still long enough to make her count accurate.

"Chruachan!" came the hoa.r.s.e cry from the MacDonald fire, stilling them all in shock.

She saw a man-shape fall, struck down by another, and then a taunting answer sang out in a deeper voice than she could manage, filling the moonlight and moor with the hated MacDonald slogan. "Fraoch Eilean!"

Cat was immobile. "Robbie-" she breathed. " 'Tis Robbie they've caught-"

"Run!" Dougal's undependable voice broke even as Colin scrambled to mount his garron.

"Come down from there-" Cat lunged up and caught fistfuls of Colin's carelessly pinned plaid. She jerked him away from his saddle. "If they've got Robbie and Jamie, 'tis for us to get them free!"

"Us?" Dougal shook his head as Colin, pulled awry by his sister, got up from the ground. Plaid torn free of its brooch fell in coils around his ankles. "We're but three, and you're not but a la.s.s-"

Cat shut her hand over the handle of her father's dirk. "Even a la.s.s is better than a coward, aye? All we have to do is distract them, make them think there are more of us. Jamie is still out there-will ye come? 'Tis for Robbie!"

Their faces were taut and white. Dougal and Colin exchanged frightened glances, then looked back at her.

"Have you broken your lug-holes?" she demanded. " 'Tis our brother they've got-MacDonalds have got!"

Dougal nodded reluctantly. His voice was a man's, for once. "We'll leave the garrons here. We're quieter on foot."

Cat grinned. She was impatient now. She rose to skyline herself against the deeper night; it was time to do the task.

"Chruachan!" she shouted again, loosing her garron, and turned sharply to pelt down the hill. "Chru- She ran headlong into a plaid-swathed, bonneted man rising from the heather with a dirk a'glint in one fist. The other hand closed itself firmly around her upper arm and yanked her onto her toes. "Fraoch Eilean, "he said lightly, "has a better sound to't!"

Cat filled her lungs with air. "Run!"

Dougal with Colin deserted.

-run-oh, run-She grinned fiercely at the MacDonald whose face, against the flames, registered surprise; he had not realized how many Campbells were huddled behind the slope. She saw it in his eyes, in his mouth, in the tautening of the flesh over his cheekbones, bled dry of blood in the firelight.

The grin fell off her mouth. He was a MacDonald. She was a Campbell. "Chruachan, " she said hoa.r.s.ely, and spat in the dirt at his feet.

He shook her. He shook her, as if she were merely a puppy guilty of misbehavior. "No more," he snapped, clutching her arm more fiercely.

Cat tested the MacDonald's grip once, then went with him without further physical protest as he led her downslope toward the fire. She slipped and slid in scree and loose gravel, but his grasp never relaxed. By the time they reached the fire her arm felt more like a piece of wood than a human limb.

There were five of them, not ten. And none of them all the way grown. They were, Cat realized in stabbing dismay, not so much older than Robbie himself, if any older at all; one or two perhaps younger.

She looked at them one by one, marking youthful faces, thin and pale; dilated, darting eyes; rigid, expectant expressions.

She could not help herself. She looked, stared hard, examined . . . No Alasdair Og . . . The response was immediate: overwhelming relief. Her bonnie prince with the speckled hair was not among the thieves.

She sought Robbie then, feeling the heat of guilt in her face, the shame for her thought on behalf of a MacDonald when MacDonalds had captured them. He stood with a dirk at his spine and another threatening his side. His own dirk and sgian dhu had been tossed aside, out of reach; Cat's borrowed dirk was yanked roughly from her belt and flung on top of Robbie's with a dull metallic clank. Firelight flashed on steel.

Robbie's expression was grim as he watched her brought close to the light. He was cut along a cheekbone, his mouth swollen and bloodied. His hands were free, but empty, and like to stay that way: two MacDonalds with naked dirks stood at either side reminding him what it felt like to have steel stuck into flesh.

She felt the p.r.i.c.k of the same against a rib, digging through plaid and shirt; felt the numbness invading the fingers of her captive arm. She smelled whisky and ripe wool, the sharp pungency of stretched nerves.

"Naught but a lad," one of the MacDonalds murmured, staring hard at Cat, then grinned sidelong at Robbie. "D'ye bring the bairns along when you go cattle-lifting?"

Robbie put up his b.l.o.o.d.y chin. "You're no' so old yourselves, aye? Is there a beard among ye?"

There was not. Cat saw a tightening of mouths, a narrowing of eyes. Firelight sparked on steel as a dirk point niggled at Robbie.

She bit her tongue on a protest. To them she was a lad. She knew instinctively it was best they believed her so.

Wood popped in the fire, startling twitches in them all. Robbie grimaced as a dirk point cut flesh. Cat waited stiffly. No one said anything. There was no sound at all save for the crackle of the fire, and the grit of brogans on stone. She swallowed tightly, staring hard at Robbie. He would do something. He would.

She shivered involuntarily, then winced as the grip on her arm spasmed shut. She felt tension in the air, sensed a subtle, increasing anxiety, and realized with a twitch of surprise that none of their captors knew what to do. The men were off with Atholl, or raiding Argyll's lands; the young men left behind had gone reiving for cattle, not for people, and were none of them experienced at dealing with captured Campbells.

"Who are you?" one asked sharply. "Which Campbell are you?"

Cat stared wide-eyed at her brother, begging guidance; it came as a single raised shoulder: 'answer them as you will.' She swallowed hard again, then made her voice gruff. "Colin."

"Colin? Colin? Colin and Robert?" One of the MacDonalds by Robbie grinned. "The drukken man has a son named Robbie, and a son named Colin. Have we caught Glenlyon's bairns?"

The 'drukken man.' Humiliation stung. She saw the same response in Robbie's face: a taut, angry mortification that MacDonalds should know Glenlyon's weakness and bait his children with it.

"Glenlyon's bairns?" another asked, and a third made a vulgar joke about the Laird of Glen Lyon and sheep.

The MacDonald who held Cat's arm dug the dirk point into her rib. It was a small pain, a petty taunt meant to force acknowledged submission; Cat squirmed off the point with her lip caught between her teeth and swore mutely to give him nothing.

"Are you a sheep, then? Have you wool on your head?" He p.r.i.c.ked her again, giggling, then abruptly s.n.a.t.c.hed off her bonnet. "Have ye-" But the taunt died out on hiss of shock as coiled braids fell down.

"-la.s.s," someone blurted.

Another hooted. "-ewe-"

Robbie's anguish was eloquent, his helplessness exquisite. But acknowledgment was swift. They'll no' be expecting a la.s.s to fight-Cat made a fist of her free hand and swung with all her might as she wheeled sharply toward her captor. The blow landed square on his nose. "Chruachan!" she shouted furiously as the blood burst forth in a torrent.

Crying out as Cat's fist struck his nose, the MacDonald fell back. Robbie lunged as the others moved. "Dinna touch her-" He tried to tear his arms free. "Cat-Cat run-"

Cat staggered away. "Robbie!"

"-Cat-run-" He struggled again, drawing their attention away from her.

It nearly was successful. Startled MacDonalds grabbed for him, shouting frantically at one another not to let the Campbell go.

"Cat-run-"

She stumbled, fell, scrabbled up again.

Robbie cried out furiously. Cat swung around . . . saw the struggle, the steel, the awkward scramble; saw the tangle of scrabbling limbs as they pulled her brother down. One of them sat on the upthrust rump, pressing Robbie's body flat; another lay athwart his shoulders with an elbow dug into an ear.

I canna leave him here . . . Cat could no longer see her brother's face. Beneath the cl.u.s.ter of kilted MacDonalds she could no longer see much at all of Glenlyon's heir, nor the scatter of dirks and sgian dhu tossed carelessly on the ground. They lay beneath her brother, beneath the pile of bodies.

Her captor nursed his nose, hawking and spitting blood. Cat s.n.a.t.c.hed up rocks and began hurling them at MacDonalds.

Several of Cat's stones struck flesh. Then the MacDonald whose nose she had broken garbled something unintelligible and caught a flopping braid, roughly jerking her down. Screeching, Cat sprawled; he jerked again, then dragged her across rocky soil. One thick MacDonald wrist was pressed against his streaming nose.

She clamped a hand around the braid near her scalp to reduce the pain and tugging even as she scrabbled with her other hand, hunting rocks. The MacDonald saw it, jerked again, then began to wind the braid around his wrist. He would pull her in, she saw, until he owned more than her braid.

Someone shouted something. Cat understood none of it. But abruptly the MacDonald who restrained her released his grip.

Cat lay belly down against hard ground. She twisted her head toward the others and saw how they scrambled up; how they backed away; how, with faces blanched white, they stared at the body lying slack upon the ground.

At Robbie Campbell's body.

"Robbie-" Cat scrabbled to hands and knees. "ROBBIE-"

The MacDonald nearest turned on her sharply; before she could rise he planted a foot against her shoulder and shoved her down again.

"We didna mean-" someone began, while another MacDonald hushed him.

"Come away," another said to his bleeding kinsman.

"But we didna mean it!" another cried. "Not this-"

"Ewan-come away!"

As Cat scrambled to her brother the MacDonalds came away, fading out of firelight into the shadows beyond. She heard the sound of horses. Heard the sound of flight. Heard the sound of MacDonalds who had killed Glenlyon's heir.

At first she could not turn him. He was heavy, and slack. Finally she gripped the cloth of Robbie's shirt and plaid and pulled him over, grunting with the effort; one arm flopped across her rigid thigh. Cat hung there, staring at the bloodied shirtfront. At the dirk, her dirk, that Robbie had grabbed as the bodies came down upon him, the weight and force driving the blade meant to defend himself into his belly instead.

Her dirk. Her father's dirk, that she had stolen.

His mouth hung slackly, crusted with dirt. Blood smeared his chin. A welt ruined a cheek. His eyes were open, transfixed by shock and death. They stared at the darkness.

To Cat, they stared at her.

"Robbie!" she shrieked.

And shrieked, and shrieked, and shrieked, until the night rang loud with her grief.

Three.

Robert Stewart of Appin hooted aloud and swept off his dusty bonnet. He ran a hasty hand through sandy hair, mussing it so thoroughly it stood up in tufts. "Christ's wounds, MacDonald, but there isna a bonnier place in Scotland, aye? Have ye no' seen such a brawlie castle?"

Indeed Dair had-in Edinburgh, Inveraray, Stirling; but he agreed amiably that indeed Castle Stalker was superior in all ways. Best to let Robbie have it, or he will argue about it all day!

But he felt a pang of guilt. To be fair, Stewart's beloved home was impressive: Castle Stalker was an upthrust, sharply rectangular explosion of perfectly quarried stone. It shook its peaks and angles free of the tiny islet of Loch Laich, offering but a few trees for character, and rose importunately from the waters of Loch Linnhe, where a man required a boat to cross from land to islet. Against the pewter blue of the loch and the viridescence of hills beyond, it loomed a rigid sentinel in defense of its inhabitants. A c.o.c.ky rival chieftain who thought to throw out the present clan and replace it with his own would find cold welcome.

He knew better. He was MacIain's son, albeit second-born; nonetheless, Dair wanted little to do with the castle and nothing at all to do with lairdship.

Stewart stood up in his stirrups. "The brawliest castle in Scotland!"

Dair grinned as the Appin men shouted clamorous accord. He purposely did not glance at his MacDonalds for fear he would see in their faces what he felt in his soul: a deep love for the harsh grandeur of Glencoe's mountain fastness, the hard-running waters of its river, the looming mountain called the Pap, the array of falls cutting vertical cliffs out of jagged granite.

Appin's Loch Laich was very like a hundred other islets scattered as pearls from a broken necklace. Castle Stalker had a hard, sharp beauty, like cut diamonds; Dair preferred the rounded cabochon that was Glencoe.

He shifted in the saddle to ease weary b.u.t.tocks. He was in no mood to visit here with Glencoe only miles away. But he and his MacDonalds had promised to aid the Stewarts in their quest to carry home vast amounts of plunder and their share of cattle. Once in Appin the ebullient young Stewart heir, oblivious to Dair's weariness and edgy restlessness, insisted MacIain's son come all the way home with him to Castle Stalker.

"You willna deny the hospitality of my house," he declared.

Dair, who had been suckled like all clansmen on the sacred Highland duty, thought of his father, of his father's insistence on proper manners, and most particularly of his father's wholly predictable reaction if his son were so benighted as to decline an invitation to sup with the heir of a clan traditionally friendly to MacDonalds.

And now the clouds had come down to ma.s.s across the land. Rain was imminent. "I'll come," Dair agreed.

Robert Stewart, leading the tail of gillies and tacksmen who tended the myriad livestock acquired from their raiding forays, nodded matter-of-fact acknowledgment; he had expected no other answer. "We'll butcher a stirk for meat, and I'll have the bard in to sing you the songs of Stewarts, and Appin." He grinned slyly. "Come get out of the rain and meet my sister, Jean, who will no doubt be much taken with all the Glencoe-men!"

Dair slanted him a sidelong glance, then squinted at the castle in elaborate skepticism. "And is she bonnie, your sister?"

Stewart's laughter rang loud, echoing against the castle perched on its rocky islet. "Good Christ, MacDonald, of course she's bonnie! She looks like me!"

Laughing in spite of himself, Dair clapped a hand to his heart in mock pain. "A brawlie blow, Stewart!"

Stewart nodded matter-of-fact agreement. "I'm verra good with dirk or sgian dhu-" He grinned. "And never cross me with a claymore in my hand!"

Dair grinned back. They were in that instant in perfect accord. But if it should ever come to a battle-He broke off the thought, looked again at the almost-laird of Appin, who seemed as sharply cognizant of the moment as he himself. If it ever comes to a battle, I want Robert Stewart at my side.

Of such men, of such ruthless, reckless, resolute men was a stronger Scotland born.

Cat's trews had come to be torn. She did not recall how, only that the threadbare seat had at some point surrendered its meager strength and abjured responsibility for guarding her dignity.

She had no dignity. She had no mind to care. She had only a wild grief that drove her ruthlessly through the darkness, stumbling and staggering her way along the narrow track in an effort to go home. There is Robbie-Robbie to tend-If she could reach Chesthill, or even a tacksman's dwelling, someone would help her do it. She would not fail him in this, albeit she failed him otherwise.