"Now, what's up, Kay?" He drank the contents of one cup.

"I've been dying to learn what the lab found out."

He had a blank look on his face.

"Which foods at the Christmas tea had the peanut products in them?"

He still didn't say anything.

"You had the food analyzed on Les Hollings table, didn't you?"

He burped. "Excuse me, Kay. Oh yeah. The food. I asked for the food from Les' table, but Dr. Lee said it had been thrown away with all of the other leftovers. He apologized for the mistake. I looked in the kitchen. There wouldn't have been any way to distinguish the food from Les' table with any of the other food."

I had a heavy feeling in the pit of my stomach. I couldn't believe it. "The food samples were destroyed!"

"Now calm down, Kay."

"Dr. Lee told me he would make sure that the staff packaged the food to give to you." Why hadn't he? Did he have something to hide? I couldn't take another doctor from the free clinic being a murderer as was the case almost two months ago. What was it with the people in Sudbury Falls?

"Well he didn't. It was an accident. Could be some of the kitchen help cleared the tables before he had a chance to say anything. It doesn't matter much. Peanuts were found in Hollings' stomach contents. Speaking of which, did you see the trays of food out there?" He looked at his watch and drank down the second cup of punch.

I looked across the desk at the tipsy lout in front of me. "Why didn't your officers handle collecting the evidence themselves? This is a police investigation! As far as we knew, the person responsible had access to that kitchen, and your men left them alone with the evidence!"

Chief Kirk dropped his cup on the table, looking a bit taken aback at being chastised for his handling of the situation. He wiped some sweat that was trickling down from his forehead. Then put his hand up in a calming gesture.

"Kay, all signs point to the same conclusion: this being an accidental death. The new coroner reported it as such. There's no need to treat this like it was an underhanded murder! Accept the fact that something terrible has happened to a good man, but it was an accident. Please try to enjoy your Christmas with your family."

"So you're definitely ruled out criminal intent?"

He stood up and walked over to the door, opening it. "Would you like another cup of punch?" He smiled weakly.

I got up and walked to the door, not returning his smile. I heard Alvin and the Chipmunks coming from the other room. "Merry Christmas," Kirk said as I left.

"Merry Christmas." When I made it to the reception area, I saw some of the police officers dancing. I glanced over my shoulder as I opened the door to leave. Kirk was back over at the punch bowl. I shook my head.

Will's car was parked out front when I pulled up. Thank goodness, he made it home. I opened up the garage door.

Will was in the kitchen. He had found the stash of cutout cookies. "Will...Merry Christmas!" I gave him a big hug. "I'm glad you're home. How was the drive?"

"Slid a few times. Lots of cars in the ditch. I see Dad frosted the snowmen." He stuffed the rest of a cookie in his mouth.

I laughed. "Somethings you just don't grow out of."

"When's Andy getting here?"

"Soon, I hope. So how does it feel to be a college graduate, home for the holidays, and then off to Madison to start your new job?"

"I'm glad to be out of school. The job's a little scary. What if I can't do it?"

"Will, you'll do great." I kissed his forehead. "By the way, I bought a gift for Frances' mom."

"About that...I had it wrong. They're not coming here for Christmas dinner. I'll be going over to Frances' Christmas night to exchange gifts. I'll give her mom the present then. What did you get?"

"A beautiful silk scarf."

Will made a face.

"She'll love it, Will. I'd like to have it myself."

"Where's Dad?"

"Downtown. Doing some shopping."

"I still have some gifts I need to get."

Like Father, like son. Will went upstairs. "You'll probably run into him," I called up the stairs after him.

I took off my coat and hung it up. Before I put my apron back on, I looked at the gifts under the tree. Were there any for me from Phil? I found a flat box about the size of a large hardcover book. Was this the big surprise, or was Andrew bringing it? Phil might still be out buying it too, I supposed. This was probably something else.

Andy and Rose made it through the snowstorm in time for everything. Phil and Will had returned a bit earlier and sneaked off to the basement storage room, where the wrapping paper was kept.

We sat down at the dining room table with our "Christmas Carol" feast and said grace. The table was beautiful with my mom's dishes and the glowing candles. Phil made a Christmas toast, ending with "God bless us, everyone" in a Tiny Tim falsetto. Everyone cheered as glass clinked against glass, followed by knives and forks against china. I smiled looking around the table; our little family was all together on this most important evening, having a great time. All was good in the world.

After dinner and a small emergency with lighting the plum pudding, we went into the living room. We had a tradition on Christmas Eve of playing Christmas songs on the instrument of one's choice. Andy played "Greensleeves" on his alto saxophone and then he and Rose played "Run, Run, Rudolph" on guitars. Next, Will played Feliz Navidad on his guitar and sang. We stood around the piano and sang as Phil played several Christmas carols. I did my best with "Silver Bells" on the piano, playing guitar chords with my left hand and "finger picking" with my right.

Phil poured champagne for everyone, and then we sat down and exchanged gifts. Everyone received a sweater from me. It was starting to be a signature gift kind of thing. Also I gave everyone, including myself, a greeting card saying that a donation was given in their name to Save the Children, an organization which impacts the lives of children and families in poverty.

Andy was our supplier of books each Christmas. He always had mysteries for me, which I loved. This year he had also provided me with the non-fictional title, Private Eye: How to Improve your Skills at Sleuthing, Surveillance, and Solving Mysteries. I smiled when I saw it and looked over at Phil, who rolled his eyes, when he read it, but smiled too. "Sorry this comes a little late, but you can save it for next time." Andy smiled.

"There better never be a next time," Phil mumbled under his breath to me, then turned to accept his gift from Andy.

I received a Monet umbrella from Rose, and Will gave me a digital recorder since, according to him, I had been so fascinated with his when he had listened to a lecture on it at home. Phil gave the usual music related things to the boys. The last present I opened was from Phil. It was a lovely scarf. I loved it, but I didn't think he would be whispering on the phone about a scarf. My big surprise must still be coming! I flung the scarf around my neck and gave Phil a big kiss.

We decided to walk the seven blocks to Christmas Eve Mass at St. Mary's. The snow had tapered off. Everyone's twinkling lights were on, as were the sky's. The moon lit the way through the snow. While walking, I started humming Christmas carols. Soon we were singing. A few people that we met along the way joined in. We stopped singing and listened to the church bells when they started to ring.

Chapter Five.

Thursday, December 25 Christmas Christmas dawned, all calm and all bright. Everyone slept in. I crept down the stairs to avoid waking anyone, and turned the tree lights on. Had Phil put the secret present under the tree for me to find this morning? Not seeing one, I walked into the kitchen, made a pot of coffee, and glanced at the clock. Our guests would be arriving for Christmas dinner at one o'clock, giving me five hours to get everything ready. Turning on Christmas music softly in the kitchen, I started humming as I put a ham and asparagus strata together. Thoughts of Christmas memories from long ago, with my parents and brothers and sisters, brought a smile to my face.

When I turned around, I saw Phil standing in the doorway watching me.

"Merry Christmas, Kay!" He walked over, put his arms around me, brushing my face with his lips.

I smiled. "Merry Christmas! You're up early." I ran my finger over the shape of his lips. Then I looked at him a little funny. If Phil was planning to surprise me with an extravagent gift, he was doing a good job of disguising the fact. I turned and put the strata in the oven.

"It already smells fantastic."

I started peeling a mango for the fruit salad. Phil hugged me from behind. I didn't know if I would be able to finish making breakfast. But everyone would be down soon. I looked down at what I was doing. I had peeled the mango down to the pit. I reached for another.

"Ham and asparagus strata."

He twirled me around and kissed me again. Maybe this was my Christmas surprise. An attentive, adoring husband. I'd take it!

"Morning, Mom and Dad," Will said, yawning as he came into the kitchen. What's for breakfast?"

"Merry Christmas, Will!"

"Oh...Merry Christmas! When's everyone coming?"

I glanced at the clock. "Soon enough. We'll be ready to eat breakfast in about a half an hour."

Andy and Rose came into the kitchen in their pajamas. "Merry Christmas, everyone."

"Merry Christmas, you two," I said. "Everyone's up early."

"Then let's open our Christmas stockings," Will said.

We headed into the living room and sat down. Will took the handmade stockings down and handed them out. I had given everyone a paperback that I thought they'd enjoy. Will gave me a pair of gold hoop earrings, and Andy and Rose, a lovely candle. Phil usually gave each person a CD. My gift from him wasn't in that shape. I tore off the gift wrap and threw it down. It was a book on Italy.

I looked up at Phil. "What's this?"

"Kay, we're going to Italy. You and I."

Andy and Will looked at me. "Aren't you going to say anything, Mom?"

"I'm in shock. I can't believe it! I love you, Phil!" I went over and hugged him, then waved the book around triumphantly as the others clapped.

The timer went off. "Italy!" I said as I waltzed into the kitchen and took the strata out of the oven. Phil had certainly exceeded expectations this time! Soon we all gathered at the kitchen table for our Christmas breakfast. The dining room table was already set for dinner.

After a shower, I spent the rest of morning in the kitchen getting dinner ready. Occasionally Andrew or Phil would pop in to help a little. I could hear the 1938 version of "A Christmas Carol" on in the family room. It was one of those movies that you can watch over and over again. My thoughts drifted to Sarah Moeller. I hoped she and her friends were having a reprive from thinking about Les' death today. Soon, I was thinking about sunny Sicily again.

Around noon, the door bell rang. "They're already here?" I said in disbelief under my breath. I took off my apron and went to answer the door just as Phil came down the steps, all showered and looking handsome in a suit.

"Surprise! Merry Christmas! We're early," Phil's brother Tommy said, standing on the porch.

I smiled at Phil. "Yes, you are." Great surprise. Phil's brother Tom and my obsessive sister-in-law Margo. Their arms were loaded full of plastic Tupperware containers, plus a fruit cake. "Merry Christmas!" Phil and I said.

"Kay, Margo's looking forward to helping you out with Christmas dinner." Phil looked over at me raising his eyebrows. Andrew and Will, who were now at the front door, stood grinning.

I clenched my jaw. More like take over Christmas dinner. "How thoughtful, Margo, it's so sweet of you to want to help. But, I'd appreciate if you'd just enjoy your Christmas. Guests should be guests. Please, just enjoy yourself." I forced a smile. Would she buy it? My sister-in-law thought she was queen-of-every-kitchen. Everything had to be done her way. It wouldn't be so terrible, if she knew how to cook. Kay, remember it's Christmas.

Tommy looked towards Margo and she at him. "Something smells good in here," he said as he handed me the fruit cake and walked into the house. "Nonsense. Margo wants to help you."

"I insist!" Margo said without a smile.

"Let me help you with all of those containers. You shouldn't have brought all of this food. We have plenty." An extra hour with Margo. My menu, ruined. Of that, I was sure.

Phil patted his little brother on the shoulder. "Tommy, how's it going?"

"Busy. You know, work." Tommy's eyes shifted in Will's direction. "Will, I heard you're starting your new job soon," he said, as they went into the living room.

Margo went straight into the kitchen. I followed with the containers and the fruitcake and put them on the counter. She took off her coat, handed it to me, and took a Christmas apron out of her large purse. I wondered if she had a chef's hat in there as well. She put on her apron and proceeded to lift up each lid of the pots on the stove, systemically tasting everything. "Well, we can rescue that," I heard her say under her breath as I left to hang up her coat.

Going into the living room, I heard a knock on the door. I opened the door to find Deirdre and Mike, Elizabeth and John standing on the doorstep, with packages in their arms, singing.

Here we come a-wassailing Among the leaves so green; Here we come a-wand'ring So fair to be seen.

Love and joy come to you....

Everyone came to the door to listen, other than Margo. "Lovely voices!" I said, and clapped when they finished. "Come in. I am so glad you're here." I had never been so glad to see anyone.

"Kay, what's wrong?" Deirdre asked in a low voice. I must have looked desperate.

Deirdre could always sense when something was wrong. "Margo's in the kitchen."

"Oh." Deirdre's eyebrows drew together.

"You poor thing," Elizabeth added. She handed me another fruitcake.

I was about to close the door when I spotted Phil's aunt and uncle coming out of the car at the end of the driveway. I waved and waited for them outside on the porch, Elizabeth's fruitcake in hand, as they walked up to the house. I looked over at Ted's house. I saw the curtain in the living room twitch. Hmm...Did we have a new neighbor?

"Merry Christmas, Kay!" We hugged.

"So happy you could make it," I said.

"Lovely home," Uncle Ben said. "Sudbury Falls looks like a nice little town."

They handed me a wrapped round package. "Better put this in the refrigerator. It's Uncle Ben's favorite," Aunt Mary said. She looked down at Elizabeth's fruitcake. "Looks like you'll have plenty."

I glanced once more at Ted's house before closing the door. The curtain was still.

Everyone sat in the living room visiting, other than Chef Margo. Phil took drink orders. I had plates of appetizers on various tables and passed those around. Aunt Mary commented on our beautiful Christmas tree and the other decorations. Elizabeth stood up and walked over to get another nibble. She wore a short, low-cut, forest green dress that looked like it was spray painted on, except that it got even lower when she bent over the tray of appetizers. I had remembered to keep the heat turned up.

Across the room I saw Uncle Ben look over at Aunt Mary and wink at her. How sweet, I thought. They've been married for what, almost sixty years? Then as Elizabeth passed him, I saw Ben wink at her as well, after he gave her the once-over, three times, and ran his hand over his thinning hair.

I went back in the kitchen and watched Margo work like a whirling dervish, adding salt and other spices, ruining my meal.