"Something less eye-catching might be better suited to our purpose."

Cosca drew himself up and snapped out a vibrating salute. "General Murcatto, I will do my straining utmost to obey your orders!"

"Don't strain. Man of your age, you might rupture something. Take Friendly with you, once the assaults begin." The convict shrugged, and went back to his dice.

"We will most nobly strip the dead to their naked arses!" Cosca turned towards the stairs, but was brought up short by the sight in the bay. "Ah! Duke Orso's fleet has joined the fun." He could just see ships moving on the horizon, white sails marked with the black cross of Talins.

"More guests for Duke Salier," said Vitari.

"He always was a conscientious host, but I'm not sure even he can be prepared for so many visitors at once. The city is entirely cut off." And Cosca grinned into the wind.

"A prison," said Friendly, and almost with a smile of his own.

"We are helpless as rats in a sack!" snapped Morveer. "You speak quite as if that were a good thing."

"Five times I have been under siege, and always quite relished the experience. It has a wonderful way of limiting the options. Of freeing the mind." Cosca took a long breath in through his nose and blew it happily out. "When life is a cell, there is nothing more liberating than captivity."

The Forlorn Hope Fire.

Visserine by night had become a place of flame and shadow. An endless maze of broken walls, fallen roofs, jutting rafters. A nightmare of disembodied cries, ghostly shapes flitting through the darkness. Buildings loomed, gutted shells, the eyeless gaps of window and doorway screaming open, fire spurting out, licking through, tickling at the darkness. Charred beams stabbed at the flames and they stabbed back. Showers of white sparks climbed into the black skies, and a black snow of ash fell softly the other way. The city had new towers now, crooked towers of smoke, glowing with the light of the fires that gave them birth, smudging out the stars.

"How many did we get the last time?" Cosca's eyes gleamed yellow from the flames across the square. "Three was it?"

"Three," croaked Friendly. They were safe in the chest in his room: the armour of two Talinese soldiers, one with the square hole left by a flatbow bolt, and the uniform of a slight young lieutenant he had found crushed under a fallen chimney. Bad luck for him, but then Friendly supposed it was his side throwing the fire everywhere.

They had catapults beyond the walls, five on the west side of the river, and three on the east. They had catapults on the twenty-two white-sailed ships in the harbour. The first night, Friendly had stayed up until dawn watching them. They had thrown one hundred and eighteen burning missiles over the walls, scattering fires about the city. Fires shifted, and burned out, and split, and merged one with another, and so they could not be counted. The numbers had deserted Friendly, and left him alone and afraid. It had taken but six short days, three nights times two, for peaceful Visserine to turn to this.

The only part of the city untouched was the island on which Duke Salier's palace stood. There were paintings there, Murcatto said, and other pretty things that Ganmark, the leader of Orso's army, the man they were here to kill, wished to save. He would burn countless houses, and countless people in them, and order murder night and day, but these dead things of paint had to be protected. Friendly thought this was a man who should be put in Safety, so that the world outside could be a safer place. But instead he was obeyed, and admired, and the world burned. It seemed all turned around, all wrong. But then Friendly could not tell right from wrong, the judges had told him so.

"You ready?"

"Yes," lied Friendly.

Cosca flashed a crazy grin. "Then to the breach, dear friend, once more!" And he trotted off down the street, one hand on the hilt of his sword, the other clasping his hat to his head. Friendly swallowed, then followed, lips moving silently as he counted the steps he took. He had to count something other than the ways he could die.

It only grew worse the closer they got to the city's western edge. The fires rose up in terrible magnificence, creaking and roaring, towering devils, gnawing at the night. They burned Friendly's eyes and made them weep. Or perhaps he wept anyway, to see the waste of it. If you wanted a thing, why burn it? And if you did not want it, why fight to take it from someone else? Men died in Safety. They died there all the time. But there was no waste like this. There was not enough there to risk destroying what there was. Each thing was valued.

"Bloody Gurkish fire!" Cosca cursed as they gave another roaring blaze a wide berth. "Ten years ago no one had dreamed of using that stuff as a weapon. Then they made Dagoska an ash-heap with it, knocked holes in the walls of the Agriont with it. Now no sooner does a siege begin than everyone's clamouring to blow things up. We liked to torch a building or two in my day, just to get things moving, but nothing like this. War used to be about making money. Some degree of modest misery was a regrettable side effect. Now it's just about destroying things, and the more thoroughly the better. Science, my friend, science. Supposed to make life easier, I thought."

Lines of sooty soldiers tramped by, armour gleaming orange with reflected flames. Lines of sooty civilians passed buckets of water from hand to hand, desperate faces half-lit by the glow of unquenchable fires. Angry ghosts, black shapes in the sweltering night. Behind them, a great mural on a shattered wall. Duke Salier in full armour, sternly pointing the way to victory. He had been holding a flag, Friendly thought, but the top part of the building had collapsed, and his raised arm along with it. Dancing flames made it look as if his painted face was twitching, as if his painted mouth was moving, as if the painted soldiers around him were charging onwards to the breach.

When Friendly was young, there had been an old man in the twelfth cell on his corridor who had told tales of long ago. Tales of the time before the Old Time, when this world and the world below were one, and devils roamed the earth. The inmates had laughed at that old man, and Friendly had laughed at him too, since it was wise in Safety to do just as others did and never to stand out. But he had gone back when no one else was near, to ask how many years, exactly, it had been since the gates were sealed and Euz shut the devils out of the world. The old man had not known the number. Now it seemed the world below had broken through the gates between again, flooding out into Visserine, chaos spreading with it.

They hurried past a tower in flames, fire flickering in its windows, pluming up from its broken roof like a giant's torch. Friendly sweated, coughed, sweated more. His mouth was endlessly dry, his throat endlessly rough, his fingertips chalky with soot. He saw the toothed outline of the city's walls at the end of a street strangled with rubble.

"We're getting close! Stay with me!"

"I... I..." Friendly's voice croaked to nothing on the smoky air. He could hear a noise, now, as they sidled down a narrow alley, red light flickering at its end. A clattering and clashing, a surging tide of furious voices. A noise like the great riot had made in Safety, before the six most feared convicts, Friendly among them, had agreed to put a stop to the madness. Who would stop the madness here? There was a boom that made the earth shudder, and a ruddy glare lit the night sky.

Cosca slipped up to the trunk of a scorched tree, keeping low, and crouched against it. The noise grew louder as Friendly crept after, terribly loud, but his heart pounding in his ears almost drowned it out.

The breach was no more than a hundred strides off, a ragged black patch of night torn from the city wall and clogged with heaving Talinese troops. They crawled like ants over the nightmare of fallen masonry and broken timbers that formed a ragged ramp down into a burned-out square at the city's edge. There might have been an orderly battle when the first assault came, but now it had dissolved into a shapeless, furious mle, defenders crowding in from barricades thrown up before the gutted buildings, attackers fumbling their way on, on through the breach, adding their mindless weight to the fight, their breathless corpses to the carnage.

Axe and sword blades flashed and glinted, pikes and spears waved and tangled, a torn flag or two hung limp over the press. Arrows and bolts flitted up and down, from the Talinese crowding outside the walls, from defenders at their barricades, from a crumbling tower beside the breach. While Friendly watched, a great chunk of masonry was sent spinning down from the top of the wall and into the boiling mass below, tearing a yawning hole through them. Hundreds of men, struggling and dying by the hellish glare of burning torches, of burning missiles, of burning houses. Friendly could hardly believe it was real. It all looked false, fake, a model staged for a lurid painting.

"The breach at Visserine," he whispered to himself, framing the scene with his hands and imagining it hanging on some rich man's wall.

When two men set out to kill each other, there is a pattern to it. A few men, for that matter. A dozen, even. With a situation like that, Friendly had always been entirely comfortable. There is a form to be followed, and by being faster, stronger, sharper, you can come out alive. But this was otherwise. The mindless press. Who could know when you would be pushed, by the simple pressure of those behind, onto a pike? The awful randomness. How could you predict an arrow, or a bolt, or a falling rock from above? How could you see death coming, and how could you avoid it? It was one colossal game of chance with your life as the stake. And like the games of chance at Cardotti's House of Leisure, in the long run, the players could only lose.

"Looks like a hot one!" Cosca screamed in his ear.

"Hot?"

"I've been in hotter! The breach at Muris looked like a slaughter yard when we were done!"

Friendly could hardly bring himself to speak, his head was spinning so much. "You've been... in that?"

Cosca waved a dismissive hand. "A few times. But unless you're mad you soon tire of it. Looks like fun, maybe, but it's no place for a gentleman."

"How do they know who's on whose side?" hissed Friendly.

Cosca's grin gleamed in his soot-smeared face. "Guesswork, mostly. You just try to stay pointed in the right direction and hope for the... ah."

A fragment had broken from the general mle and was flowing forwards, bristling with weapons. Friendly could not even tell whether they were the besiegers or the besieged, they hardly seemed like men at all. He turned to see a wall of spears advancing down the street from the opposite direction, shifting light gleaming on dull metal, across stony faces. Not individual men, but a machine for killing.

"This way!" Friendly felt a hand grab his arm, shove him through a broken doorway in a tottering piece of wall. He stumbled and slipped, pitched over on his side. He half-ran, half-slid down a great heap of rubble, through a cloud of choking ash, and lay on his belly beside Cosca, staring up towards the combat in the street above. Men crashed together, killed and died, a formless soup of rage. Over their screams, their bellows of anger, the clash and squeal of metal, Friendly could hear something else. He stared sideways. Cosca was bent over on his knees, shaking with ill-suppressed mirth.

"Are you laughing?"

The old mercenary wiped his eyes with a sooty finger. "What's the alternative?"

They were in a kind of darkened valley, choked with rubble. A street? A drained canal? A sewer? Ragged people picked through the rubbish. Not far away a dead man lay face down. A woman crouched over the corpse with a knife out, in the midst of cutting the fingers from one limp hand for his rings.

"Away from that body!" Cosca lurched up, drawing his sword.

"This is ours!" A scrawny man with tangled hair and a club in his hand.

"No." Cosca brandished the blade. "This is ours." He took a step forwards and the scavenger stumbled back, falling through a scorched bush. The woman finally got through the bone with her knife, pulled the ring off and stuffed it in her pocket, flung the finger at Cosca along with a volley of abuse, then scuttled off into the darkness.

The old mercenary peered after them, weighing his sword in his hand. "He's Talinese. His gear, then!"

Friendly crept numbly over and began to unbuckle the dead man's armour. He pulled the backplate away and slid it into his sack.

"Swiftly, my friend, before those sewer rats return."

Friendly had no mind to delay, but his hands were shaking. He was not sure why. They did not normally shake. He pulled the soldier's greaves off, and his breastplate, rattling into the sack with the rest. Four sets, this would be. Three plus one. Three more and they would have one each. Then perhaps they could kill Ganmark, and be done, and he could go back to Talins, and sit in Sajaam's place, counting the coins in the card game. What happy times those seemed now. He reached out and snapped off the flatbow bolt in the man's neck.

"Help me." Hardly more than a whisper. Friendly wondered if he had imagined it. Then he saw the soldier's eyes were wide open. His lips moved again. "Help me."

"How?" whispered Friendly. He undid the hooks and eyes on the man's padded jacket and, as gently as he could, stripped it from him, dragging the sleeve carefully over the oozing stumps of his severed fingers. He stuffed his clothes into the sack, then gently rolled him back over onto his face, just as he had found him.

"Good!" Cosca pointed towards a burned-out tower leaning precariously over a collapsed roof. "That way, maybe?"

"Why that way?"

"Why not that way?"

Friendly could not move. His knees were trembling. "I don't want to go."

"Understandable, but we should stay together." The old mercenary turned and Friendly caught his arm, words starting to burble out of his mouth.

"I'm losing count! I can't... I can't think. What number are we up to, now? What... what... have I gone mad?"

"You? No, my friend." Cosca was smiling as he clapped his hand down on Friendly's shoulder. "You are entirely sane. This. All this!" He swept his hat off and waved it wildly around. "This is insanity!"

Mercy and Cowardice Shivers stood at the window, one half open and the other closed, the frame around him like the frame around a painting, watching Visserine burn. There was an orange edge to his black outline from the fires out towards the city walls-down the side of his stubbly face, one heavy shoulder, one long arm, the twist of muscle at his waist and the hollow in the side of his bare arse.

If Benna had been there he'd have warned her she was taking some long chances, lately. Well, first he'd have asked who the big naked Northman was, then he'd have warned her. Putting herself in the middle of a siege, death so close she could feel it tickling at her neck. Letting her guard down even this much with a man she was meant to be paying, walking the soft line with those farmers downstairs. She was taking risks, and she felt that tingling mix of fear and excitement that a gambler can't do without. Benna wouldn't have liked it. But then she'd never listened to his warnings when he was alive. If the odds stand long against you, you have to take long chances, and Monza had always had a knack for picking the right ones.

Up until they killed Benna and threw her down the mountain, at least.

Shivers' voice came out of the darkness. "How'd you come by this place, anyway?"

"My brother bought it. Long time ago." She remembered him standing at the window, squinting into the sun, turning to her and smiling. She felt a grin tug at the corner of her own mouth, just for a moment.

Shivers didn't turn, now, and he didn't smile either. "You were close, eh? You and your brother."

"We were close."

"Me and my brother were close. Everyone that knew him felt close to him. He had that trick. He got killed, by a man called the Bloody-Nine. He got killed when he'd been promised mercy, and his head nailed to a standard."

Monza didn't much care for this story. On the one hand it was boring her, on the other it was making her think of Benna's slack face as they tipped him over the parapet. "Who'd have thought we had so much in common? Did you take revenge?"

"I dreamed of it. My fondest wish, for years. I had the chance, more'n once. Vengeance on the Bloody-Nine. Something a lot of men would kill for."

"And?"

She saw the muscles working on the side of Shivers' head. "The first time I saved his life. The second I let him go, and chose to be a better man."

"And you've been wandering round like a tinker with his cart ever since, peddling mercy to anyone who'll take? Thanks for the offer, but I'm not buying."

"Not sure I'm selling anymore. I been acting the good man all this time, talking up the righteous path, hoping to convince myself I done the right thing walking away. Breaking the circle. But I didn't, and that's a fact. Mercy and cowardice are the same, just like you told me, and the circle keeps turning, whatever you try. Taking vengeance... it might not answer no questions. It sure won't make the world a fairer place or the sun shine warmer. But it's better'n not taking it. It's a damn stretch better."

"I thought you were all set on being Styria's last good man."

"I've tried to do the right thing when I could, but you don't get a name in the North without doing some dark work, and I done my share. I fought beside Black Dow, and Crummock-i-Phail, and the Bloody-Nine his self, for that matter." He gave a snort. "You think you got cold hearts down here? You should taste the winters where I come from." There was something in the set of his face she hadn't seen before, and hadn't expected to. "I'd like to be a good man, that's true. But you need it the other way, then I know how."

There was silence for a moment, while they looked at each other. Him leaning against the window frame, her sprawled on the bed with one hand behind her head.

"If you really are such a snow-hearted bastard, why did you come back for me? In Cardotti's?"

"You still owe me money."

She wasn't sure if he was joking. "I feel warm all over."

"That and you're about the best friend I've got in this mad fucking country."

"And I don't even like you."

"I'm still hoping you'll warm to me."

"You know what? I might just be getting there."

She could see his grin in the light from beyond the window. "Letting me in your bed. Letting Furli and the rest stay in your house. If I didn't know better I'd be thinking I'd peddled you some mercy after all."

She stretched out. "Maybe beneath this harsh yet beautiful shell I'm really still a soft-hearted farmer's daughter, only wanting to do good. You think of that?"

"Can't say I did."

"Anyway, what's my choice? Put them out on the street, they might start talking. Safer here, where they owe us something."

"They're safest of all in the mud."

"Why don't you go downstairs and put all our minds at rest, then, killer? Shouldn't be a problem for the hero that used to carry Black Now's luggage."

"Dow."

"Whoever. Best put some trousers on first, though, eh?"

"I'm not saying we should've killed 'em or nothing, I'm just pointing out the fact. Mercy and cowardice are the same, I heard."

"I'll do what needs doing, don't worry. I always have. But I'm not Morveer. I'm not murdering eleven farmers just for my convenience."

"Nice to hear, I guess. All those little people dying in the bank didn't seem to bother you none, long as one of 'em was Mauthis."

She frowned. "That wasn't the plan."

"Nor the folk at Cardotti's."

"Cardotti's didn't go quite the way I had in mind either, in case you didn't notice."

"I noticed pretty good. The Butcher of Caprile, they call you, no? What happened there?"

"What needed doing." She remembered riding up in the dusk, the stab of worry as she saw the smoke over the city. "Doing it and liking it are different things."

"Same results, no?"

"What the hell would you know about it? I don't remember you being there." She shook the memory off and slid from the bed. The careless warmth of the last smoke was wearing through and she felt strangely awkward in her own scarred skin, crossing the room with his eyes on her, stark naked but for the glove still on her right hand. The city, and its towers, and its fires spread out beyond the window, blurred through the bubbly glass panes in the closed half. "I didn't bring you up here to remind me of my mistakes. I've made enough of the bastards."