"He's hoping I won't make good," thought Joe. "But I will! I must!"

It may have been because of Joe's natural nervousness, or because the scrub team was determined to show that they could bat even their own pitcher, that was the cause of so many runs coming in during the first inning. No one could rightly say, but the fact remained that the runs did come in, and it began to look bad for the 'varsity.

"I told you how it would be--putting in a green pitcher," complained Mr.

Benson.

"Perhaps," admitted the head coach. "But wait a bit. Joe isn't as green as he looks. Wait until next inning."

And he was justified, for Joe got himself well in hand, and the 'varsity, as if driven to desperation by another defeat staring them in the face so near to the Amherst game, batted as they never had before.

Avondale was all but knocked out of the box, and the scrub captain subst.i.tuted another pitcher, who did much better. Joe's former rival almost wept at his own inability.

Meanwhile our hero was himself again, and though he did give three men their bases on b.a.l.l.s, he allowed very few hits, so that the 'varsity took the game by a good margin, considering their bad start.

"That's the way to do it!" cried Captain Hatfield, when the contest was over.

"Do it to Amherst," was the comment of the head coach.

"We will!" cried the members of the first team.

"Good work, Matson," complimented Hatfield. "Can you do it again?"

"Maybe--if I get the chance," laughed Joe, who was on an elevation of delight.

"Oh, I guess you'll have to get the chance," spoke the captain. He did not notice that Weston was close behind him, but Joe did, and he saw the look of anger and almost hate that pa.s.sed over the face of the pitcher.

"He looks as though he'd like to bite me," murmured Joe. "And yet it's all a fair game. I may get knocked out myself. But even then I'm not going to give up. I'm in this to stay! If not at Yale, then somewhere else."

If Joe imagined that his work that day had been without flaws he was soon to be disillusioned, for Mr. Hasbrook, coming up to him a little later, pointed out where he had made several bad errors in judgment, though they had not resulted in any gain for the scrub.

"Still," said the head coach, "you don't want to make them, for with a sharp team, and some of the big college nines playing against you, those same errors would lose the game." And he proceeded to give Joe some good advice.

When Avondale, the twice-humiliated pitcher, walked off the diamond that afternoon, he was joined by Weston, who linked his arm in that of the scrub twirler.

"Well, we're both in the same boat," remarked Avondale. "A better man has ousted us."

"Not at all--nothing of the sort!" cried Weston, and his voice showed how much he was nervously wrought up. "I don't admit for a minute that Matson can pitch better than I can."

"Well, I do, in my own case, and the coaches seem to in yours."

"I'm a little out of form to-day," admitted Weston, quickly. "I'll be all right to-morrow, and I'll pitch against Amherst."

"It'll be a great game," spoke Avondale.

"Maybe. But say, what do you think of a fellow like him--a regular country clod-hopper--coming here, anyhow?"

"Who do you mean?"

"Matson. What right has he got to b.u.t.t in at a college like Yale, and displace the fellows who have worked hard for the nine?"

"The right of ability, I suppose."

"Ability nothing! He doesn't belong here, and he ought to be made to quit."

"Well, I confess I don't like to lose the place I worked so hard for, and I don't see much chance of making the 'varsity now," admitted Avondale; "but at the same time I must give Matson credit for his work."

"Bah! It's only a flash in the pan. He can't last. I think I could make him quit if I wanted to."

"How?"

"Would you join me in a little trick if we could?"

"I don't know. What do you mean?" and Avondale looked curiously at his companion.

"I mean that red paint business and the spoiling of the ancient ma.n.u.scripts. If it was known who did it he'd get fired."

"You don't mean to say Matson had a hand in that!" cried Avondale aghast.

"I'm not saying anything. But if it could be shown that he did it, he'd not pitch for Yale--that's sure. Shall I say any more? Remember I'm making no cracks yet. But I know some things about Matson no one else knows." This was true enough, but Avondale did not take it in the sense in which it could have been truthfully said, but, rather, as Weston meant he should--wrongly.

Now Avondale had one fault. He was too easily led. He was brilliant, full of promise, and a jolly chap--hail-fellow-well-met with everyone, and that is not the best thing in the world, though it makes for temporary popularity. Avondale was his own worst enemy, and many a time he had not the courage to say "no!" when the utterance of it would have saved him from trouble. So when Weston thus temptingly held out the bait, Avondale nibbled.

"Shall I say any more?" went on the other. "Remember, you've got to be as tight as a drum on this."

"Of course. I--er--I--that is----"

"Come over here and I'll tell you something," went on the 'varsity pitcher, and the two were soon in close conversation.

CHAPTER XIX

THE ANONYMOUS LETTER

"Have you seen the _News_?" gasped Jimmie Lee, bursting into the room of Joe and his chum one afternoon, following some baseball practice. "It's great!"

"You mean have we _heard_ the news; don't you?" questioned Spike. "You can hear news, but not see it, that is unless the occurrence which makes news happens to come under your own observation. Where is your logic, you heathen? _Seen_ news!"

"Yes, that's what I mean!" snapped Jimmie. "I mean have you seen the last copy of the Yale _News_?"

"No; what is it?" asked Joe quickly. "Something about the baseball nine?"

"No, it's about those musty old ma.n.u.scripts that got spoiled the time Professor Hardee slipped on his doorsteps in the red paint."

"What about 'em?" demanded Joe, thinking of the time he had seen Weston slipping into his room, trying to conceal his hand on which was a scarlet smear. "What's new?"

"Why, it seems that some learned high-brow society wrote on to borrow them, to prove or disprove something that happened in the time of Moses, and they had to be refused as the sheepskins are illegible. The powers that be tried to clean off the paint, but it took some of the lettering with it, and Prof. Hardee and some of his friends are wild over the loss. The _News_ says it's irreparable, and there's even an editorial on it."